Patel Roma, Thiagarajan Prarthana
National Health Service.
BMJ Qual Improv Rep. 2014 Aug 26;3(1). doi: 10.1136/bmjquality.u205194.w2142. eCollection 2014.
Weekend admissions to hospital have been associated with adverse patient outcomes, including higher morbidity and mortality risk in general medicine and surgery. The reasons behind this are likely to be multifactorial and include reduced senior clinician-led care, decreased overall workforce, and ineffective or incomplete handover. With the advent of shift-work patterns, robust handover between medical teams is of paramount importance, particularly before weekends. This has been reflected in recent publications by Royal College of Physicians (acute care toolkit 1: handover, May 2011), that identified handover as an error-prone process and issued guidelines designed to optimise its effectiveness. The aim of this project was to evaluate weekend patient mortality and success of handover on the medical high dependency unit of a large teaching hospital in the United Kingdom, before and after introduction of a structured handover tool on Friday afternoons during May 2013. This unit is registrar-led at weekends. Weekend mortality decreased from 43% in March 2013 to 22% in May 2013 (odds ratio 0.37, 95% CI 0.19-0.68, p=0.07). Documentation of resuscitation status and escalation plans increased from 75% in March 2013 to 93% in May 2013. There was universal positive feedback from registrars involved with the handover tool, who provided senior cover during the weekends in May 2013. It is hoped that structured, written handover will ultimately become commonplace in this unit and will improve patient safety at weekends.
周末入院治疗与不良患者结局相关,包括在内科和外科中更高的发病率和死亡风险。其背后的原因可能是多方面的,包括资深临床医生主导的护理减少、整体劳动力减少以及交接无效或不完整。随着轮班工作模式的出现,医疗团队之间进行有力的交接至关重要,尤其是在周末之前。这一点在皇家内科医师学院最近的出版物(《急性护理工具包1:交接》,2011年5月)中有所体现,该出版物将交接认定为一个容易出错的过程,并发布了旨在优化其有效性的指南。本项目的目的是评估在英国一家大型教学医院的内科高依赖病房引入结构化交接工具前后,周末患者死亡率及交接的成功率。该病房在周末由住院医师主导。周末死亡率从2013年3月的43%降至2013年5月的22%(优势比0.37,95%置信区间0.19 - 0.68,p = 0.07)。复苏状态和升级计划的记录从2013年3月的75%增加到2013年5月的93%。参与交接工具的住院医师给出了一致的积极反馈,他们在2013年5月的周末提供高级护理。希望结构化的书面交接最终能在该病房变得普遍,并能在周末提高患者安全。