Silano Marco, Agostoni Carlo, Sanz Yolanda, Guandalini Stefano
Unit of Human Nutrition and Health, Istituto Superiore di Sanità, Roma, Italy.
Pediatric Clinic, Department of Clinical Sciences and Community Health, University of Milan, Fondazione IRCCS Cà Granda, Ospedale Maggiore Policlinico, Milan, Italy.
BMJ Open. 2016 Jan 25;6(1):e009163. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2015-009163.
To review the evidence for the association of breast feeding, breastfeeding duration or the timing of gluten introduction and the later development of celiac disease (CD).
Systematic review.
We searched MEDLINE, via PubMed, EMBASE and Web of Science, for studies published up to 31 August 2015 investigating the association of breastfeeding duration, breast feeding at the moment of gluten introduction or the timing of gluten introduction and the later development of CD. Prospective studies had to enrol infants/children at high risk of CD. For retrospective studies, participants had to be children or adults with CD. The paper quality was assessed by means of a GRADE score and the bias risk was assessed by the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale (for observational cohort studies) and Cochrane Collaboration's tool (for randomised trials).
Out of 149 retrieved papers, 48 were considered in depth and 16 were included in this review (9 were prospective and 2 were interventional). We found that neither duration of breastfeeding nor breastfeeding at time of gluten introduction nor the delayed introduction of gluten during weaning were effective in preventing later development of CD.
Currently, there is no evidence on the optimal breastfeeding duration or the effects of avoiding early (<4 months of age) or late (≥ 6 or even at 12 months) gluten introduction in children at risk of CD. Accordingly, no specific general recommendations about gluten introduction or optimal breastfeeding duration can be presently provided on evidence-based criteria in order to prevent CD.
回顾母乳喂养、母乳喂养持续时间或麸质引入时间与乳糜泻(CD)后期发病之间关联的证据。
系统评价。
我们通过PubMed检索MEDLINE、EMBASE和Web of Science,查找截至2015年8月31日发表的研究,这些研究调查了母乳喂养持续时间、麸质引入时的母乳喂养情况或麸质引入时间与CD后期发病之间的关联。前瞻性研究必须纳入患CD风险高的婴儿/儿童。对于回顾性研究,参与者必须是患有CD的儿童或成人。通过GRADE评分评估论文质量,通过纽卡斯尔-渥太华量表(用于观察性队列研究)和Cochrane协作工具(用于随机试验)评估偏倚风险。
在检索到的149篇论文中,48篇进行了深入考虑,16篇纳入本综述(9篇为前瞻性研究,2篇为干预性研究)。我们发现,母乳喂养持续时间、麸质引入时的母乳喂养情况或断奶期间延迟引入麸质均不能有效预防CD后期发病。
目前,尚无证据表明对于有患CD风险的儿童,最佳母乳喂养持续时间是多久,以及避免过早(<4月龄)或过晚(≥6月龄甚至12月龄)引入麸质会产生何种影响。因此,目前无法基于循证标准就麸质引入或最佳母乳喂养持续时间给出具体的一般性建议,以预防CD。