Dhakal Krishna P, Chevalier Lizette R
Environmental Resources and Policy, Southern Illinois University Carbondale, Carbondale, IL, USA.
Civil and Environmental Engineering, Southern Illinois University Carbondale, Carbondale, IL, USA.
Environ Manage. 2016 May;57(5):1112-24. doi: 10.1007/s00267-016-0667-5. Epub 2016 Feb 2.
Traditional urban stormwater management involves rapid removal of stormwater through centralized conveyance systems of curb-gutter-pipe networks. This results in many adverse impacts on the environment including hydrological disruption, groundwater depletion, downstream flooding, receiving water quality degradation, channel erosion, and stream ecosystem damage. In order to mitigate these adverse impacts, urban stormwater managers are increasingly using green infrastructure that promote on-site infiltration, restore hydrological functions of the landscape, and reduce surface runoff. Existing stormwater governance, however, is centralized and structured to support the conventional systems. This governance approach is not suited to the emerging distributed management approach, which involves multiple stakeholders including parcel owners, government agencies, and non-governmental organizations. This incongruence between technology and governance calls for a paradigm shift in the governance from centralized and technocratic to distributed and participatory governance. This paper evaluates how five US cities have been adjusting their governance to address the discord. Finally, the paper proposes an alternative governance model, which provides a mechanism to involve stakeholders and implement distributed green infrastructure under an integrative framework.
传统的城市雨水管理涉及通过路缘石-排水沟-管网的集中输送系统快速排除雨水。这对环境造成了许多不利影响,包括水文紊乱、地下水枯竭、下游洪水、受纳水体水质退化、河道侵蚀以及溪流生态系统破坏。为了减轻这些不利影响,城市雨水管理者越来越多地采用绿色基础设施,这种设施能促进雨水就地渗透、恢复景观的水文功能并减少地表径流。然而,现有的雨水治理是集中式的,其结构是为了支持传统系统。这种治理方法不适用于新兴的分布式管理方法,后者涉及多个利益相关者,包括地块所有者、政府机构和非政府组织。技术与治理之间的这种不一致要求治理模式从集中式和技术官僚式向分布式和参与式治理转变。本文评估了美国五个城市如何调整其治理以解决这种不协调问题。最后,本文提出了一种替代治理模式,该模式提供了一种机制,以便在综合框架下让利益相关者参与并实施分布式绿色基础设施。