Ramirez Amelie G, Chalela Patricia, Gallion Kipling J, Muñoz Edgar, Holden Alan E, Burhansstipanov Linda, Smith Selina A, Wong-Kim Evaon, Wyatt Stephen W, Suarez Lucina
UT Health Science Center at San Antonio.
Native American Cancer Initiatives.
J Health Dispar Res Pract. 2015 Fall;8(4):124-135.
This study examined interest in and attitudes toward genetic testing in 5 different population groups.
The survey included African American, Asian American, Latina, Native American, and Appalachian women with varying familial histories of breast cancer. A total of 49 women were interviewed in person. Descriptive and nonparametric statistical techniques were used to assess ethnic group differences.
Overall, interest in testing was high. All groups endorsed more benefits than risks. There were group differences regarding endorsement of specific benefits and risks: testing to "follow doctor recommendations" (p=0.017), "concern for effects on family" (p=0.044), "distrust of modern medicine" (p=0.036), "cost" (p=0.025), and "concerns about communication of results to others" (p=0.032). There was a significant inverse relationship between interest and genetic testing cost (p<0.050), with the exception of Latinas, who showed the highest level of interest regardless of increasing cost.
Cost may be an important barrier to obtaining genetic testing services, and participants would benefit by genetic counseling that incorporates the unique cultural values and beliefs of each group to create an individualized, culturally competent program. Further research about attitudes toward genetic testing is needed among Asian Americans, Native Americans, and Appalachians for whom data are severely lacking. Future study of the different Latina perceptions toward genetic testing are encouraged.
本研究调查了5个不同人群对基因检测的兴趣和态度。
该调查纳入了有不同乳腺癌家族史的非裔美国女性、亚裔美国女性、拉丁裔女性、美国原住民女性和阿巴拉契亚女性。总共对49名女性进行了面对面访谈。采用描述性和非参数统计技术来评估种族差异。
总体而言,检测兴趣较高。所有群体都认可基因检测的益处多于风险。在对特定益处和风险的认可方面存在群体差异:检测以“遵循医生建议”(p = 0.017)、“担心对家人的影响”(p = 0.044)、“对现代医学的不信任”(p = 0.036)、“费用”(p = 0.025)以及“担心检测结果告知他人”(p = 0.032)。兴趣与基因检测费用之间存在显著的负相关关系(p < 0.050),但拉丁裔女性除外,她们无论费用增加,兴趣水平都最高。
费用可能是获得基因检测服务的一个重要障碍,参与者将受益于基因咨询,这种咨询应纳入每个群体独特的文化价值观和信仰,以创建一个个性化的、具有文化胜任力的项目。对于严重缺乏数据的亚裔美国人、美国原住民和阿巴拉契亚人,需要进一步开展关于基因检测态度的研究。鼓励未来对拉丁裔对基因检测的不同看法进行研究。