Mora-Relucio Raquel, Núñez-Nagy Susana, Gallego-Izquierdo Tomás, Rus Alma, Plaza-Manzano Gustavo, Romero-Franco Natalia, Ferragut-Garcías Alejandro, Pecos-Martín Daniel
Free Professional Practice, 28031 Madrid, Spain.
Physical Therapy Department, University of Alcalá, Alcalá de Henares, 28806 Madrid, Spain.
Evid Based Complement Alternat Med. 2016;2016:6059719. doi: 10.1155/2016/6059719. Epub 2016 Jan 10.
The purpose was to evaluate the interexaminer reliability of experienced and inexperienced examiners on location and classification of myofascial trigger points (MTrPs) in two epicondylar muscles and the association between the MTrP found and the diagnosis of lateral epicondylalgia (LE). Fifty-two pianists (some suffered LE) voluntarily participated in the study. Three physiotherapists (one inexperienced in myofascial pain) examined, located, and marked MTrPs in the extensor carpi radialis brevis (ECRB) and extensor digitorum communis (EDC) muscles. Forearms were photographed and analyzed to establish the degree of agreement on MTrPs diagnosis. Data showed 81.73% and 77.88% of agreement on MTrP classification and 85.58% and 72.12% on MTrP location between the expert evaluators for ECRB and EDC, respectively. The agreement on MTrP classification between experienced and inexperienced examiners was 54.81% and 51.92% for ECRB and 50.00% and 55.77% for EDC. Also, agreement on MTrP location was 54.81% and 60.58% for ECRB and 48.08% and 48.08% for EDC. A strong association was found between presence of relevant MTrPs, LE diagnosis, and forearm pain when the examiners were experts. The analysis of location and classification of MTrPs in the epicondylar muscles through physical examination by experienced evaluators is reliable, reproducible, and suitable for diagnosing LE.
目的是评估经验丰富和缺乏经验的检查者在确定两块上髁肌中肌筋膜触发点(MTrP)的位置和分类方面的检查者间可靠性,以及所发现的MTrP与外侧上髁炎(LE)诊断之间的关联。52名钢琴演奏者(部分患有LE)自愿参与了该研究。三名物理治疗师(其中一名对肌筋膜疼痛缺乏经验)对桡侧腕短伸肌(ECRB)和指总伸肌(EDC)中的MTrP进行了检查、定位并标记。对前臂进行拍照和分析,以确定在MTrP诊断方面的一致程度。数据显示,ECRB和EDC的专家评估者在MTrP分类上的一致率分别为81.73%和77.88%,在MTrP位置上的一致率分别为85.58%和72.12%。经验丰富和缺乏经验的检查者在ECRB的MTrP分类上的一致率分别为54.81%和51.92%,在EDC上分别为50.00%和55.77%。同样,在ECRB的MTrP位置上的一致率分别为54.81%和60.58%,在EDC上分别为48.08%和48.08%。当检查者为专家时,发现相关MTrP的存在、LE诊断和前臂疼痛之间存在强关联。通过经验丰富的评估者进行体格检查来分析上髁肌中MTrP的位置和分类是可靠的、可重复的,且适用于LE的诊断。