Trani Jean-Francois, Ballard Ellis, Peña Juan B
Brown School, Institute of Public Health, Social System Design Lab and Prevention Research Center, Washington University in St Louis, St Louis, MO, USA.
Brown School, Social System Design Lab, Washington University in St Louis, St Louis, MO, USA.
Soc Sci Med. 2016 Mar;153:258-65. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2016.02.024. Epub 2016 Feb 21.
Despite evidence that stigma of disability is frequently reflected through stereotyping and often results in mental distress, very limited literature demonstrates the pathways through which stereotyping has an impact on mental health. Drawing from a large sample of 1449 participants interviewed between December 2012 and September 2013 from an Afghan community-based rehabilitation program, we examined the structure of stigma associated with disability in Afghanistan. Labeling and negative stereotypes, associated with a specific cause of disability, result in social exclusion that in turn impacts mental health. Using structural equation modeling with latent variables, we examined the mediation effect of stereotypes associated with disability on mental distress and anxiety. We found a mediating role of social exclusion between stereotypes and mental distress but only in the case of persons with disabilities from birth. Comparing the total effect of 'disabled at birth' and mental distress 0.195 (95% CI: 0.018-0.367) the effect size of this mediation effect was 0.293 (95% CI: 0.173-0.415). There was no significant direct effect between 'disabled at birth' and mental distress once mediation effect was accounted for in our model. These findings suggest that a multipronged policy approach that recognizes the driving forces of stigma and promotes social participation directly alongside psychosocial interventions on mental distress of persons with disabilities is necessary to achieve wellbeing for a group that has been historically and systematically excluded from development interventions.
尽管有证据表明,残疾污名经常通过刻板印象表现出来,并常常导致精神痛苦,但极少有文献揭示刻板印象对心理健康产生影响的途径。我们从2012年12月至2013年9月间对阿富汗一个社区康复项目的1449名参与者进行的大规模访谈样本中,研究了阿富汗与残疾相关的污名结构。与特定残疾原因相关的标签化和负面刻板印象会导致社会排斥,进而影响心理健康。我们使用带有潜在变量的结构方程模型,研究了与残疾相关的刻板印象对精神痛苦和焦虑的中介作用。我们发现社会排斥在刻板印象和精神痛苦之间起中介作用,但仅适用于先天性残疾人。比较“先天性残疾”与精神痛苦的总效应0.195(95%置信区间:0.018 - 0.367),这种中介效应的效应大小为0.293(95%置信区间:0.173 - 0.415)。在我们的模型中考虑中介效应后,“先天性残疾”与精神痛苦之间没有显著的直接效应。这些发现表明,需要采取多管齐下的政策方法,既要认识到污名的驱动因素,又要在对残疾人精神痛苦进行心理社会干预的同时,直接促进社会参与,以便让这个在历史上和系统上被排除在发展干预之外的群体实现幸福安康。