Robinson Jill Oliver, Carroll Thomas M, Feuerman Lindsay Z, Perry Denise L, Hoffman-Andrews Lily, Walsh Rebecca C, Christensen Kurt D, Green Robert C, McGuire Amy L
Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, TX, USA
Rice University, Houston, TX, USA.
J Empir Res Hum Res Ethics. 2016 Feb;11(1):21-30. doi: 10.1177/1556264615624078. Epub 2016 Feb 28.
An increasing number of individuals are being recruited to whole genome sequencing (WGS) research. When asked hypothetically, the majority of the public express willingness to participate in this type of research, yet little is known about how many individuals will actually consent to research participation or what they perceive the risks to be. The MedSeq Project is a clinical trial exploring WGS in clinical care. We documented primary reason(s) for declining participation and reviewed audio-recorded informed consent sessions to identify participants' concerns. Of 514 individuals recruited, 173 (34%) actively declined, 205 (40%) enrolled, and the remaining 136 (26%) were ineligible, unresponsive or waitlisted. Although the majority of active decliners cited logistical barriers, 40% cited risks related to the ethical, legal, and social implications (ELSI) of WGS research. Participants similarly discussed ELSI-related concerns but felt the potential benefits of participation outweighed the risks. Findings provide insight into the perspectives of potential WGS research participants and identify potential barriers to participation.
越来越多的人被招募到全基因组测序(WGS)研究中。在进行假设性询问时,大多数公众表示愿意参与此类研究,但对于实际会同意参与研究的人数以及他们所认为的风险知之甚少。MedSeq项目是一项在临床护理中探索WGS的临床试验。我们记录了拒绝参与的主要原因,并回顾了录音的知情同意过程以确定参与者的担忧。在招募的514人中,173人(34%)主动拒绝,205人(40%)参与,其余136人(26%)不符合条件、无回应或在等待名单中。虽然大多数主动拒绝者提到了后勤障碍,但40%的人提到了与WGS研究的伦理、法律和社会影响(ELSI)相关的风险。参与者也讨论了与ELSI相关的担忧,但认为参与的潜在益处大于风险。研究结果为潜在的WGS研究参与者的观点提供了见解,并确定了参与的潜在障碍。