Atay Gamze, Kayahan Bahar, Çınar Betül Çiçek, Saraç Sarp, Sennaroğlu Levent
Department of Otolaryngology, Hacettepe University Faculty of Medicine, Ankara, Turkey.
Department of Audiology, Hacettepe University Faculty of Medicine, Ankara, Turkey.
Balkan Med J. 2016 Jan;33(1):87-93. doi: 10.5152/balkanmedj.2015.15216. Epub 2016 Jan 1.
Sudden sensorineural hearing loss (SSNHL) is still a complex and challenging process which requires clinical evidence regarding its etiology, treatment and prognostic factors. Therefore, determination of prognostic factors might aid in the selection of proper treatment modality.
The aim of this study is to analyze whether there is correlation between SSNHL outcomes and (1) systemic steroid therapy, (2) time gap between onset of symptoms and initiation of therapy and (3) audiological pattern of hearing loss.
Retrospective chart review.
Patients diagnosed at our clinic with SSNHL between May 2005 and December 2011 were reviewed. A detailed history of demographic features, side of hearing loss, previous SSNHL and/or ear surgery, recent upper respiratory tract infection, season of admission, duration of symptoms before admission and the presence of co-morbid diseases was obtained. Radiological and audiological evaluations were recorded and treatment protocol was assessed to determine whether systemic steroids were administered or not. Treatment started ≤5 days was regarded as "early" and >5 days as "delayed". Initial audiological configurations were grouped as "upward sloping", "downward sloping", "flat" and "profound" hearing loss. Significant recovery was defined as thresholds improved to the same level with the unaffected ear or improved ≥30 dB on average. Slight recovery was hearing improvement between 10-30dB on average. Hearing recovery less than 10 dB was accepted as unchanged.
Among the 181 patients who met the inclusion criteria, systemic steroid was administered to 122 patients (67.4%), whereas 59 (32.6%) patients did not have steroids. It was found that steroid administration did not have any statistically significant effect in either recovered or unchanged hearing groups. Early treatment was achieved in 105 patients (58%) and 76 patients (42%) had delayed treatment. Recovery rates were no different in these two groups; however, when unchanged hearing rates were compared, it was statistically significantly lower in the early treatment group (p<0.05). When hearing outcomes were compared according to initial audiological pattern, significant recovery and unchanged hearing rates did not differ between groups; however, slight recovery rate was highest in the "flat" type audiological configuration (p<0.05).
According to this patient series, oral steroid therapy does not have any influence on the outcomes of SSNHL. However, mid-frequency hearing loss of flat type and initiation of treatment earlier than 5 days from the onset of symptoms, seem to have positive prognostic effects. Further randomized controlled subject groups might contribute to determine prognostic factors of SSNHL.
突发性感音神经性听力损失(SSNHL)仍是一个复杂且具有挑战性的过程,在其病因、治疗及预后因素方面需要临床证据。因此,确定预后因素可能有助于选择合适的治疗方式。
本研究旨在分析SSNHL的预后与(1)全身用类固醇治疗、(2)症状发作与治疗开始之间的时间间隔以及(3)听力损失的听力学模式之间是否存在相关性。
回顾性病历审查。
对2005年5月至2011年12月期间在我院诊断为SSNHL的患者进行回顾。获取了详细的人口统计学特征、听力损失侧别、既往SSNHL和/或耳部手术史、近期上呼吸道感染、入院季节、入院前症状持续时间以及合并疾病情况。记录放射学和听力学评估结果,并评估治疗方案以确定是否使用了全身用类固醇。治疗开始时间≤5天被视为“早期”,>5天被视为“延迟”。初始听力学构型分为“上升型”、“下降型”、“平坦型”和“极重度”听力损失。显著恢复定义为阈值改善至与未受影响耳相同水平或平均改善≥30dB。轻度恢复为平均听力改善10 - 30dB。听力恢复小于10dB被视为未改变。
在符合纳入标准的181例患者中,122例(67.4%)患者接受了全身用类固醇治疗,而59例(32.6%)患者未使用类固醇。发现类固醇治疗在听力恢复或未改变的组中均无任何统计学显著效果。105例(58%)患者实现了早期治疗,76例(42%)患者接受了延迟治疗。这两组的恢复率无差异;然而,比较未改变听力率时,早期治疗组在统计学上显著更低(p<0.05)。根据初始听力学模式比较听力结果时,各组之间的显著恢复率和未改变听力率无差异;然而,“平坦型”听力学构型的轻度恢复率最高(p<0.05)。
根据本患者系列,口服类固醇治疗对SSNHL的预后没有任何影响。然而,平坦型中频听力损失以及症状发作后5天内开始治疗似乎具有积极的预后作用。进一步的随机对照研究组可能有助于确定SSNHL的预后因素。