Xue Li C, Rodrigues João P G L M, Dobbs Drena, Honavar Vasant, Bonvin Alexandre M J J
Brief Bioinform. 2017 May 1;18(3):458-466. doi: 10.1093/bib/bbw027.
Although many advanced and sophisticated ab initio approaches for modeling protein-protein complexes have been proposed in past decades, template-based modeling (TBM) remains the most accurate and widely used approach, given a reliable template is available. However, there are many different ways to exploit template information in the modeling process. Here, we systematically evaluate and benchmark a TBM method that uses conserved interfacial residue pairs as docking distance restraints [referred to as alpha carbon-alpha carbon (CA-CA)-guided docking]. We compare it with two other template-based protein-protein modeling approaches, including a conserved non-pairwise interfacial residue restrained docking approach [referred to as the ambiguous interaction restraint (AIR)-guided docking] and a simple superposition-based modeling approach. Our results show that, for most cases, the CA-CA-guided docking method outperforms both superposition with refinement and the AIR-guided docking method. We emphasize the superiority of the CA-CA-guided docking on cases with medium to large conformational changes, and interactions mediated through loops, tails or disordered regions. Our results also underscore the importance of a proper refinement of superimposition models to reduce steric clashes. In summary, we provide a benchmarked TBM protocol that uses conserved pairwise interface distance as restraints in generating realistic 3D protein-protein interaction models, when reliable templates are available. The described CA-CA-guided docking protocol is based on the HADDOCK platform, which allows users to incorporate additional prior knowledge of the target system to further improve the quality of the resulting models.
尽管在过去几十年里已经提出了许多先进且复杂的从头开始建模蛋白质-蛋白质复合物的方法,但在有可靠模板的情况下,基于模板的建模(TBM)仍然是最准确且应用最广泛的方法。然而,在建模过程中有许多不同的方式来利用模板信息。在此,我们系统地评估并基准测试了一种使用保守界面残基对作为对接距离约束的TBM方法[称为α碳原子-α碳原子(CA-CA)引导对接]。我们将其与其他两种基于模板的蛋白质-蛋白质建模方法进行比较,包括一种保守的非成对界面残基约束对接方法[称为模糊相互作用约束(AIR)引导对接]和一种基于简单叠加的建模方法。我们的结果表明,在大多数情况下,CA-CA引导对接方法优于叠加优化方法和AIR引导对接方法。我们强调了CA-CA引导对接在具有中等到大的构象变化以及通过环、尾巴或无序区域介导的相互作用的情况下的优越性。我们的结果还强调了对叠加模型进行适当优化以减少空间冲突的重要性。总之,当有可靠模板时,我们提供了一种基准化的TBM方案,该方案使用保守的成对界面距离作为约束来生成逼真的三维蛋白质-蛋白质相互作用模型。所描述的CA-CA引导对接方案基于HADDOCK平台,该平台允许用户纳入目标系统的额外先验知识以进一步提高所得模型的质量。