Stevens Elizabeth A, Walker Melodee A, Vaughn Sharon
1 University of Texas at Austin, USA.
J Learn Disabil. 2017 Sep/Oct;50(5):576-590. doi: 10.1177/0022219416638028. Epub 2016 Apr 11.
Fluent word reading is hypothesized to facilitate reading comprehension by improving automatic word reading, thus releasing a reader's cognitive resources to focus on meaning. Many students with learning disabilities (LD) struggle to develop reading fluency, which affects reading comprehension. This synthesis extends Chard, Vaughn, and Tyler's (2002) review, synthesizing fluency intervention research from 2001 to 2014. The search yielded 19 studies examining reading fluency and comprehension outcomes of reading fluency interventions for students with LD in kindergarten through 5th grade. Results showed repeated reading (RR), multicomponent interventions, and assisted reading with audiobooks produced gains in reading fluency and comprehension. Providing a model of fluent reading and performance feedback, using easier level text, setting a performance criterion, and practicing RR with peers also contributed to improved outcomes. Findings suggest that RR remains the most effective intervention for improving reading fluency for students with LD. Limitations include sample size, only three group design studies, and infrequent use of standardized measures.
流畅的单词阅读被认为通过提高自动单词阅读能力来促进阅读理解,从而释放读者的认知资源以专注于语义理解。许多学习障碍(LD)学生在发展阅读流畅性方面存在困难,这会影响阅读理解。本综述扩展了查德、沃恩和泰勒(2002年)的综述,综合了2001年至2014年的流畅性干预研究。检索结果得到19项研究,这些研究考察了幼儿园至五年级LD学生阅读流畅性干预的阅读流畅性和理解结果。结果表明,反复阅读(RR)、多成分干预以及使用有声读物辅助阅读在阅读流畅性和理解方面取得了进步。提供流畅阅读的示范和表现反馈、使用难度较低的文本、设定表现标准以及与同伴一起练习反复阅读也有助于改善结果。研究结果表明,反复阅读仍然是提高LD学生阅读流畅性最有效的干预措施。局限性包括样本量、仅三项组间设计研究以及标准化测量使用频率低。