Hodges-Simeon Carolyn R, Hanson Sobraske Katherine N, Samore Theodore, Gurven Michael, Gaulin Steven J C
Department of Anthropology, Boston University, Boston, Massachusetts, United States of America.
Department of Anthropology, University of California Santa Barbara, Santa Barbara, California, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2016 Apr 14;11(4):e0153083. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0153083. eCollection 2016.
Facial width-to-height ratio (fWHR) has been proposed as a sexually dimorphic signal in humans that develops under the influence of pubertal testosterone (T); however, no studies have examined the association between fWHR and T during the phase in which facial growth is canalized--adolescence. In a sample of adolescent Tsimane males, we evaluate the relationship between T, known T-derived traits (i.e. strength and voice pitch), and craniofacial measurements. If fWHR variation derives from T's effect on craniofacial growth during adolescence, several predictions should be supported: 1) fWHR should increase with age as T increases, 2) fWHR should reflect adolescent T (rather than adult T per se), 3) fWHR should exhibit velocity changes during adolescence in parallel with the pubertal spurt in T, 4) fWHR should correlate with T after controlling for age and other potential confounds, and 5) fWHR should show strong associations with other T-derived traits. Only prediction 4 was observed. Additionally, we examined three alternative facial masculinity ratios: facial width/lower face height, cheekbone prominence, and facial width/full face height. In contrast to fWHR, all three alternative measures show a strong age-related trend and are associated with both T and T-dependent traits. Overall, our results question the status of fWHR as a sexually-selected signal of pubertal T and T-linked traits.
面部宽高比(fWHR)被认为是人类一种受青春期睾酮(T)影响而形成的性别二态性信号;然而,尚无研究在面部生长定型的阶段——青春期,考察fWHR与T之间的关联。在一个青春期齐曼男性样本中,我们评估了T、已知的T衍生特征(即力量和嗓音音高)与颅面部测量之间的关系。如果fWHR的变化源于青春期T对颅面部生长的影响,那么应该有几个预测得到支持:1)随着T增加,fWHR应随年龄增长而增加;2)fWHR应反映青春期的T(而非成年期的T本身);3)fWHR在青春期应与T的青春期突增同步出现速度变化;4)在控制年龄和其他潜在混杂因素后,fWHR应与T相关;5)fWHR应与其他T衍生特征有强关联。仅观察到了预测4。此外,我们考察了三种替代的面部男性化比例:面部宽度/下脸高度、颧骨突出度和面部宽度/全脸高度。与fWHR不同,这三种替代测量均呈现出与年龄相关的强烈趋势,并且与T及T依赖性状均有关联。总体而言,我们的结果对fWHR作为青春期T和T相关性状的性选择信号的地位提出了质疑。