Nam Yunju, Hong Upyong
Department of Media and Communication, Konkuk University, Seoul 05029, South Korea.
Department of Media and Communication, Konkuk University, Seoul 05029, South Korea.
Brain Res. 2016 Jul 1;1642:590-602. doi: 10.1016/j.brainres.2016.04.037. Epub 2016 Apr 16.
The neural responses of Korean speakers were recorded while they read sentences that included local semantic mismatch between adjectives (A) and nouns (N) or/and global semantic mismatch between object nouns (N) and verbs (V), as well as the corresponding control sentences without any semantic anomalies. In Experiment 1 using verb-final declarative sentences (Nsubject [A-N]object V), the local A-N incongruence yielded an N400 effect at the object noun and a combination of N400 and a late negativity effect at the sentence final verb, whereas the global N-V incongruence yielded a biphasic N400 and P600 ERP pattern at the verb compared with the ERPs of same words in the control sentences respectively; in Experiment 2 using verb-initial object relative clause constructions ([Nsubject _V]rel [A-N]object …..) derived from the materials of Experiment 1, the effect of local incongruence changed notably such that not only an N400 but also an additional P600 effect was observed at the object noun, whereas the effect of the global incongruence remained largely the same (N400 and P600). Our theoretical interpretation of these results specifically focused on the reason for the P600 effects observed across different experiment conditions, which turned out to be attributable to (i) coordination of a semantic conflict, (ii) prediction disconfirmation, or (iii) argument structure processing breakdown.
在韩国人阅读包含形容词(A)和名词(N)之间的局部语义不匹配或/和宾语名词(N)与动词(V)之间的全局语义不匹配的句子以及相应的无任何语义异常的对照句子时,记录他们的神经反应。在实验1中,使用动词后置的陈述句(N主语 [A-N]宾语 V),局部A-N不一致在宾语名词处产生N400效应,在句子末尾的动词处产生N400和晚期负效应的组合,而全局N-V不一致与对照句子中相同单词的ERP相比,在动词处产生双相N400和P600 ERP模式;在实验2中,使用从实验1的材料衍生而来的动词前置的宾语关系从句结构([N主语_V]关系词 [A-N]宾语……),局部不一致的效应发生了显著变化,以至于在宾语名词处不仅观察到N400,还观察到额外的P600效应,而全局不一致的效应基本保持不变(N400和P600)。我们对这些结果的理论解释特别关注在不同实验条件下观察到的P600效应的原因,结果发现这可归因于(i)语义冲突的协调,(ii)预测的证伪,或(iii)论元结构处理故障。