Lemmens Lidwien C, de Bruin Simone R, Struijs Jeroen N, Rijken Mieke, Nijpels Giel, Baan Caroline A
National Institute for Public Health and the Environment, Centre for Nutrition, Prevention and Health Services, Bilthoven, The Netherlands.
NIVEL Netherlands Institute for Health Services Research, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Int J Integr Care. 2015 Dec 15;15:e044. doi: 10.5334/ijic.2207. eCollection 2015 Oct-Dec.
Despite the expected beneficial effects on quality of care, patient involvement in diabetes care groups, which deliver a bundled paid integrated care programme for diabetes type 2, seems to be limited. The aim of this study was to gain insight into levels and methods of patient involvement, into facilitators and barriers, and into the future preferences of care groups and patient representatives.
Semi-structured interviews were held with 10 representatives of care groups and 11 representatives of patient advocacy groups. An adapted version of Arnstein's ladder of citizen participation was used to define five levels of patient involvement.
Patient involvement in care groups was mostly limited to informing and consulting patients. Higher levels, i.e., advising, co-producing and decision-making, were less frequently observed. Care groups and patient representatives perceived largely the same barriers and facilitators and had similar preferences regarding future themes and design of patient involvement.
Constructive collaboration between diabetes care groups and patient representatives to enhance patient involvement in the future seems viable. Several issues such as the lack of evidence for effectiveness of patient involvement, differences in viewpoints on the role and responsibilities of care groups and perceived barriers need to be addressed.
尽管预期对医疗质量会产生有益影响,但患者参与为2型糖尿病提供捆绑式付费综合护理计划的糖尿病护理小组的情况似乎有限。本研究的目的是深入了解患者参与的程度和方法、促进因素和障碍,以及护理小组和患者代表未来的偏好。
对10名护理小组代表和11名患者倡导组织代表进行了半结构化访谈。采用了改编版的阿恩斯坦公民参与阶梯来定义患者参与的五个层次。
患者在护理小组中的参与大多仅限于向患者提供信息和咨询。较少观察到更高层次的参与,即提供建议、共同生产和决策。护理小组和患者代表在很大程度上感知到相同的障碍和促进因素,并且在未来患者参与的主题和设计方面有相似的偏好。
糖尿病护理小组与患者代表之间为加强未来患者参与而进行的建设性合作似乎是可行的。需要解决几个问题,如缺乏患者参与有效性的证据、护理小组在角色和责任方面的观点差异以及感知到的障碍。