Koo Malcolm, Lin Shih-Chun
Department of Medical Research, Dalin Tzu Chi Hospital, Buddhist Tzu Chi Medical Foundation, Dalin, Taiwan.
Dalla Lana School of Public Health, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Jpn J Nurs Sci. 2016 Oct;13(4):496-501. doi: 10.1111/jjns.12125. Epub 2016 May 10.
An inaccurate image of the nursing profession can negatively affect staff recruitment, resource allocation, and the perception of nursing professionalism. Previous research has investigated how nurses were portrayed in the traditional media but relatively little is known from the perspective of the Internet. Therefore, the present study aimed to explore how the nursing profession is portrayed on the Internet by using two popular sources of photographic images.
The first 100 images that were obtained using the search term "nurse" on Google Images and Shutterstock were analyzed. The distribution of the image attributes between the two websites was compared with Fisher's exact test. The text description of the images that were obtained from Shutterstock also was analyzed.
In the 171 images with at least one nurse in them, the nurses were predominately female (91%). The facial expression of the nurses was mostly smiling (85%) and 68% of the nurses had a stethoscope. For those with their hands visible in the images, 39% were holding documents, writing boards, or tablet computers and 29% were shown touching patients. Only 7% were depicted as using medical devices.
While most of the nursing images were relatively professional-looking, the nurses were portrayed only as engaging in comforting patients and recording data. Nurses who were engaged in clinical tasks or scientific activities, such as research, were absent in the portrayals. A plan needs to be developed to accurately and comprehensively represent the nursing profession on the Internet.
对护理专业不准确的形象认知会对员工招聘、资源分配以及护理专业形象的认知产生负面影响。以往研究调查了传统媒体中护士的形象呈现,但从互联网角度了解到的相对较少。因此,本研究旨在通过两种流行的摄影图像来源,探讨互联网上护理专业是如何被呈现的。
分析在谷歌图片和Shutterstock上使用搜索词“护士”获得的前100张图片。用Fisher精确检验比较两个网站上图像属性的分布情况。还对从Shutterstock获得的图片的文字描述进行了分析。
在171张至少有一名护士的图片中,护士大多为女性(91%)。护士的面部表情大多是微笑(85%),68%的护士佩戴听诊器。在图片中手部可见的护士中,39%手持文件、写字板或平板电脑,29%显示在触摸患者。只有7%被描绘为使用医疗设备。
虽然大多数护理图片看起来相对专业,但护士仅被描绘为在安慰患者和记录数据。从事临床任务或科学活动(如研究)的护士在这些呈现中缺失。需要制定一项计划,以便在互联网上准确、全面地呈现护理专业。