Department of Neurology, Caucasus Medical Center, Tbilisi, Georgia.
Danish Headache Center, Department of Neurology, Rigshospitalet Glostrup, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Headache. 2020 Jul;60(7):1465-1471. doi: 10.1111/head.13846. Epub 2020 May 27.
People with migraine have historically been depicted as "frail and perfectionist women." While these presentations are from a different cultural context, we may today still be at risk of stereotyping and stigmatizing this patient group. Portrayals of people with migraine on the Internet and in mass media offer a window of how society today views this patient group. The aim of this study was to explore how persons with migraine are being portrayed according to 2 popular sources of photographic images.
Using the search term "migraine," we retrieved the 200 highest-indexed images of people with migraine from each of 2 popular image-searching websites, Shutterstock and Google Images. For each included image, we analyzed different attributes including (1) gender; (2) age; (3) race; (4) body type; (5) posture; (6) extent of eye closure; (7) clothing attire; (8) environment/setting; (9) lighting; (10) position of left hand; and (11) position of right hand.
We included 283 images. The 283 images depicted 305 persons with migraine. The images representing persons with migraine were predominately female (82%), of adult age (90%), white (64%), and with an ectomorph body type (86%). The eyes were closed in most of the portrayals (82%). The hands were on both temporal regions at the same time in half of the portrayals (49%).
The demographics in terms of gender, race, and age reflect large population studies of migraine; however, we are concerned about the stereotypical depiction of "acute pain behavior" (ie, eye closed, hands on temples) on these images as this is inconsistent with the actual presentations of people with migraine in our clinical experience. This disparity may both derive from, and further contribute to, social stigmatization and lack of public and employer validation of migraine-related disability. We suggest that future efforts in migraine advocacy may focus on ensuring the portrayal in mass media of an accurate representation of people with migraine.
偏头痛患者历来被描绘成“脆弱和完美主义的女性”。虽然这些表现来自于不同的文化背景,但我们今天仍有可能对这一患者群体产生刻板印象和污名化。互联网和大众媒体上对偏头痛患者的描述为我们了解当今社会对这一患者群体的看法提供了一个窗口。本研究旨在探讨根据两个流行的图像来源,偏头痛患者是如何被描绘的。
使用搜索词“偏头痛”,我们从两个流行的图像搜索网站 Shutterstock 和 Google Images 中检索到 200 张索引最高的偏头痛患者图像。对于每个包含的图像,我们分析了不同的属性,包括(1)性别;(2)年龄;(3)种族;(4)体型;(5)姿势;(6)眼睛闭合程度;(7)衣着;(8)环境/背景;(9)照明;(10)左手位置;和(11)右手位置。
我们共纳入 283 张图像。这 283 张图像描绘了 305 位偏头痛患者。代表偏头痛患者的图像主要是女性(82%)、成年(90%)、白人(64%)和外胚层体型(86%)。大多数图像中眼睛是闭着的(82%)。一半的图像中双手同时放在颞部(49%)。
从性别、种族和年龄等方面来看,这些数据反映了偏头痛的大型人群研究;然而,我们对这些图像中“急性疼痛行为”(即眼睛闭上,双手放在太阳穴上)的刻板描绘表示关注,因为这与我们在临床实践中对偏头痛患者的实际表现不一致。这种差异可能既源于,也进一步导致了偏头痛相关残疾在社会上的污名化和缺乏公众和雇主的认可。我们建议,偏头痛宣传的未来工作可以集中在确保大众媒体对偏头痛患者的准确描绘。