Volandes Angelo E, Paasche-Orlow Michael K, Davis Aretha Delight, Eubanks Robert, El-Jawahri Areej, Seitz Rae
Massachusetts General Hospital, 50 Staniford Street, 9th Floor, Boston, MA, 02115, USA.
Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA.
J Gen Intern Med. 2016 Sep;31(9):1035-40. doi: 10.1007/s11606-016-3730-2. Epub 2016 May 18.
Advance care planning (ACP) seeks to promote care delivery that is concordant with patients' informed wishes. Scalability and cost may be barriers to widespread ACP, and video decision aids may help address such barriers.
Our primary hypothesis was that ACP documentation would increase in Hilo after ACP video implementation. Secondary hypotheses included increased use of hospice, fewer deaths in the hospital, and decreased costs in the last month of life.
The city of Hilo in Hawai'i (population 43,263), which is served by one 276-bed hospital (Hilo Medical Center), one hospice (the Hospice of Hilo), and 30 primary care physicians.
The intervention consisted of a single, 1- to 4-h training and access to a suite of ACP video decision aids.
Prior to implementation, the rate of ACP documentation for hospitalized patients with late-stage disease was 3.2 % (11/346). After the intervention, ACP documentation was 39.9 % (1,107/2,773) (P < 0.001). Primary care providers in the intervention had an ACP completion rate for patients over 75 years of 37.0 % (1,437/3,888) compared to control providers, who had an average of 25.6 % (10,760/42,099) (P < 0.001). The rate of discharge from hospital to hospice for patients with late-stage disease was 5.7 % prior to the intervention and 13.8 % after the intervention (P < 0.001). The average total insurance cost for the last month of life among Hilo patients was $3,458 (95 % CI $3,051 to 3,865) lower per patient after the intervention when compared to the control region.
Implementing ACP video decision aids was associated with improved ACP documentation, greater use of hospice, and decreased costs. Decision aids that promote ACP offer a scalable and cost-efficient medium to place patients at the center of their care.
预先护理计划(ACP)旨在促进与患者知情意愿相一致的护理服务提供。可扩展性和成本可能是广泛实施ACP的障碍,而视频决策辅助工具可能有助于克服这些障碍。
我们的主要假设是,在实施ACP视频后,希洛的ACP文件记录将会增加。次要假设包括临终关怀使用增加、医院死亡人数减少以及生命最后一个月成本降低。
夏威夷州的希洛市(人口43,263),由一家拥有276张床位的医院(希洛医疗中心)、一家临终关怀机构(希洛临终关怀)和30名初级保健医生提供服务。
干预措施包括一次时长1至4小时的培训以及获取一套ACP视频决策辅助工具。
在实施之前,晚期疾病住院患者的ACP文件记录率为3.2%(11/346)。干预后,ACP文件记录率为39.9%(1,107/2,773)(P<0.001)。干预组中75岁以上患者的初级保健提供者的ACP完成率为37.0%(1,437/3,888),而对照组提供者的平均完成率为25.6%(10,760/42,099)(P<0.001)。晚期疾病患者从医院转至临终关怀机构的比例在干预前为5.7%,干预后为13.8%(P<0.001)。与对照区域相比,干预后希洛患者生命最后一个月的平均总保险成本每位患者降低了3458美元(95%可信区间为3051美元至3865美元)。
实施ACP视频决策辅助工具与改善ACP文件记录、更多使用临终关怀以及降低成本相关。促进ACP的决策辅助工具提供了一种可扩展且具有成本效益的媒介,将患者置于其护理的中心位置。