Yang Lanqin, Huang Biao, Mao Mingcui, Yao Lipeng, Niedermann Silvana, Hu Wenyou, Chen Yong
Key Laboratory of Soil Environment and Pollution Remediation, Institute of Soil Science, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Nanjing, 210008, People's Republic of China.
School of the Environment, Jiangsu University, Zhenjiang, 212013, People's Republic of China.
Environ Sci Pollut Res Int. 2016 Sep;23(17):17287-97. doi: 10.1007/s11356-016-6937-1. Epub 2016 May 25.
To provide growing population with sufficient food, greenhouse vegetable production has expanded rapidly in recent years in China and sustainability of its farming practices is a major concern. Therefore, this study assessed the sustainability of greenhouse vegetable farming practices from environmental, economic, and socio-institutional perspectives in China based on selected indicators. The empirical data were collected through a survey of 91 farm households from six typical greenhouse vegetable production bases and analysis of environmental material samples. The results showed that heavy fertilization in greenhouse vegetable bases of China resulted in an accumulation of N, P, Cd, Cu, Pb, and Zn in soil, nutrient eutrophication in irrigation water, and high Cd in some leaf vegetables cultivated in acidic soil. Economic factors including decreased crop yield in conventional farming bases, limited and site-dependent farmers' income, and lack of complete implementation of subsidy policies contributed a lot to adoption of heavy fertilization by farmers. Also, socio-institutional factors such as lack of unified management of agricultural supplies in the bases operated in cooperative and small family business models and low agricultural extension service efficiency intensified the unreasonable fertilization. The selection of cultivated vegetables was mainly based on farmers' own experience rather than site-dependent soil conditions. Thus, for sustainable development of greenhouse vegetable production systems in China, there are two key aspects. First, it is imperative to reduce environmental pollution and subsequent health risks through integrated nutrient management and the planting strategy of selected low metal accumulation vegetable species especially in acidic soil. Second, a conversion of cooperative and small family business models of greenhouse vegetable bases to enterprises should be extensively advocated in future for the unified agricultural supplies management and improved agricultural extension service efficiency, which in turn can stabilize vegetable yields and increase farmers' benefits.
为了给不断增长的人口提供足够的食物,近年来中国的温室蔬菜生产迅速扩张,其种植方式的可持续性成为一个主要问题。因此,本研究基于选定的指标,从环境、经济和社会制度角度评估了中国温室蔬菜种植方式的可持续性。实证数据是通过对六个典型温室蔬菜生产基地的91个农户进行调查以及对环境物质样本进行分析收集的。结果表明,中国温室蔬菜基地的大量施肥导致土壤中氮、磷、镉、铜、铅和锌的积累,灌溉水中养分富营养化,以及在酸性土壤中种植的一些叶菜类蔬菜镉含量高。经济因素包括传统种植基地作物产量下降、农民收入有限且依赖种植地点、补贴政策缺乏全面实施,这些因素在很大程度上促使农民采用大量施肥。此外,社会制度因素,如合作社和小家庭经营模式的基地农业物资缺乏统一管理以及农业推广服务效率低下,加剧了施肥的不合理性。蔬菜种植的选择主要基于农民自身经验,而非依赖种植地点的土壤条件。因此,对于中国温室蔬菜生产系统的可持续发展,有两个关键方面。首先,必须通过综合养分管理和选择低金属积累蔬菜品种的种植策略来减少环境污染及后续健康风险,特别是在酸性土壤中。其次,未来应广泛倡导将温室蔬菜基地的合作社和小家庭经营模式转变为企业模式,以实现农业物资的统一管理并提高农业推广服务效率,进而稳定蔬菜产量并增加农民收益。