DeAngelis L M, Delattre J Y, Posner J B
Department of Neurology, Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center, New York, NY 10021.
Neurology. 1989 Jun;39(6):789-96. doi: 10.1212/wnl.39.6.789.
When a patient with cancer develops a brain metastasis, death is usually imminent, but aggressive treatment in some patients with limited or no systemic disease yields long-term survival. In such patients, delayed deleterious effects of therapy are particularly tragic. We report 12 patients who developed delayed complications of whole brain radiotherapy (WBRT) given as sole treatment (4 patients) or in combination with surgical resection (8 patients). Within 5 to 36 months (median, 14) all patients developed progressive dementia, ataxia, and urinary incontinence causing severe disability in all and leading to death in 7. No patient had tumor recurrence when neurologic symptoms began. Cortical atrophy and hypodense white matter were identified by CT in all. Contrast-enhancing lesions were seen in 3 patients; 2 of the lesions yielded radionecrosis on biopsy. Autopsies on 2 patients revealed diffuse chronic edema of the hemispheric white matter in the absence of tumor recurrence. Corticosteroids and ventriculoperitoneal shunt offered significant but incomplete improvement in some patients. The total dose of WBRT was only 2,500 to 3,900 cGy, but daily fractions of 300 to 600 cGy were employed. We believe that these fractionation schedules, several of which are used commonly, predispose to delayed neurologic toxicity, and that more protracted schedules should be employed for the safe and efficacious treatment of good-risk patients with brain metastases. The incidence of WBRT-induced dementia was only 1.9 to 5.1% in the 2 populations reviewed here; however, this underestimates the incidence because only severely affected patients could be identified from chart review.
当癌症患者发生脑转移时,通常临近死亡,但部分全身疾病局限或无全身疾病的患者接受积极治疗后可长期存活。在此类患者中,治疗的延迟有害效应尤其悲惨。我们报告了12例发生全脑放疗(WBRT)延迟并发症的患者,其中4例接受单纯WBRT治疗,8例接受WBRT联合手术切除。在5至36个月(中位时间为14个月)内,所有患者均出现进行性痴呆、共济失调和尿失禁,导致全部患者严重残疾,7例死亡。神经症状出现时无患者发生肿瘤复发。所有患者CT均显示皮质萎缩和白质低密度。3例患者可见强化病灶;其中2例病灶活检显示放射性坏死。2例患者尸检显示半球白质弥漫性慢性水肿,无肿瘤复发。皮质类固醇和脑室腹腔分流术使部分患者有显著但不完全的改善。WBRT总剂量仅2500至3900 cGy,但每日分次剂量为300至600 cGy。我们认为,这些分次方案(其中几种为常用方案)易导致延迟神经毒性,对于脑转移低风险患者的安全有效治疗,应采用更延长的分次方案。在此回顾的2组人群中,WBRT诱发痴呆的发生率仅为1.9%至5.1%;然而,这低估了发生率,因为通过病历审查仅能识别出严重受影响的患者。