Sadler Richard Casey
Department of Family Medicine, Michigan State University, 200 E 1st St, Flint, MI, 48502, USA.
Int J Health Geogr. 2016 Jun 16;15(1):19. doi: 10.1186/s12942-016-0048-6.
The availability of healthy foods in a neighborhood remains a key determinant of diet and diet-related disease in disadvantaged communities. Innovative solutions to the 'food desert' problem include the deployment of mobile markets and healthy corner store initiatives. Such initiatives, however, do not always capitalize on the principles guiding retail development and the possibilities of GIS-based data. Simultaneously, community partners are not always engaged effectively in the planning for such interventions, which limits acceptability and suitability of such work.
This paper highlights the results of a participatory mapping exercise to optimize the siting of a planned healthy food retail intervention in Flint, Michigan. Potential sites are chosen by engaging experts in a three-stage mapping process that includes the analytic hierarchy process and point allocation of five key variables (including food access, socioeconomic distress, population density, access to transit, and proximity to neighborhood centers), as well as direct mapping of suitable sites.
Results suggest a discrete set of areas-primarily in the northwestern quadrant of the city-where small-scale healthy food retail interventions might be most strategically located. Areas with the most consistent overlap between directly mapped sites and very high levels of suitability align well with neighborhoods which are distant from existing grocery stores.
As a community-based strategy, this increases the opportunity for effectively improving neighborhood access to healthy foods by optimizing the potential sites for healthy food interventions. Community partners have already been active in using these results in project planning for just such an intervention.
社区中健康食品的可获得性仍然是弱势社区饮食及与饮食相关疾病的关键决定因素。解决“食品荒漠”问题的创新方案包括部署流动市场和开展健康街角商店计划。然而,此类计划并不总是能充分利用指导零售发展的原则以及基于地理信息系统(GIS)数据的可能性。同时,社区合作伙伴并不总是有效地参与此类干预措施的规划,这限制了此类工作的可接受性和适用性。
本文重点介绍了一项参与式地图绘制活动的结果,该活动旨在优化密歇根州弗林特市一项计划中的健康食品零售干预措施的选址。通过让专家参与一个三阶段的地图绘制过程来选择潜在地点,该过程包括层次分析法以及对五个关键变量(包括食品获取、社会经济困境、人口密度、交通便利性以及与社区中心的距离)进行点分配,同时还对合适的地点进行直接绘图。
结果表明,主要在该市西北象限有一组离散的区域,在这些区域进行小规模健康食品零售干预可能具有最佳的战略位置。直接绘制的地点与非常高的适宜性之间重叠最一致的区域,与远离现有杂货店的社区吻合度很高。
作为一种基于社区的策略,这通过优化健康食品干预的潜在地点,增加了有效改善社区获取健康食品机会的可能性。社区合作伙伴已经积极地在项目规划中运用这些结果来开展此类干预措施。