Thompson Jonathan, Yoward Samantha, Dawson Pamela
York Hospital, York, UK.
York St John University, York, UK.
Musculoskeletal Care. 2017 Jun;15(2):91-103. doi: 10.1002/msc.1152. Epub 2016 Jun 21.
Physiotherapy extended scope practitioner (ESP) roles are widely utilized in the management of musculoskeletal conditions. The present article reviews the current literature, with particular emphasis on the decision-making process, patient/clinician interaction and clinical outcomes.
A systematic review of musculoskeletal extended scope practice was carried out. The review focused on the outcome of interventions, and the interactions and decision-making processes between ESPs and their patients. A wide search strategy was employed, through multiple databases, grey literature and experts in the field. Qualitative and quantitative studies alike were included and a mixed-methods synthesis approach was undertaken in analysing the findings of included studies.
A total of 476 articles were identified for inclusion, 25 of which (22 quantitative and three qualitative) meeting the criteria for full quality appraisal and synthesis. It was not possible to conduct a meta-analysis owing to data heterogeneity. The results showed high patient satisfaction with the ESP role, support for ESP staff listing patients for orthopaedic surgery, a high positive correlation of decision making between ESPs and orthopaedic surgeons and evidence of a positive impact on patient outcomes. Qualitative themes reflected the importance of ESP clinical decision making and interpersonal skills and their role in patient education.
There is broad support for the physiotherapy ESP role and evidence of favourable outcomes from ESP intervention. Clinical decisions made by ESPs correlate well with those of medical colleagues, although there is a lack of detail explaining the ESP decision-making process itself and the influences and mechanisms by which this occurs. Copyright © 2016 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
物理治疗扩展范围从业者(ESP)角色在肌肉骨骼疾病管理中得到广泛应用。本文回顾当前文献,特别强调决策过程、患者/临床医生互动及临床结果。
对肌肉骨骼扩展范围实践进行系统回顾。该回顾聚焦于干预结果,以及ESP与患者之间的互动和决策过程。采用广泛的检索策略,通过多个数据库、灰色文献及该领域专家进行检索。纳入定性和定量研究,并采用混合方法综合分析纳入研究的结果。
共识别出476篇纳入文章,其中25篇(22篇定量研究和3篇定性研究)符合全面质量评估和综合标准。由于数据异质性,无法进行荟萃分析。结果显示患者对ESP角色满意度高,支持ESP工作人员为患者安排骨科手术,ESP与骨科医生之间的决策具有高度正相关性,且有证据表明对患者预后有积极影响。定性主题反映了ESP临床决策和人际技能的重要性及其在患者教育中的作用。
对物理治疗ESP角色有广泛支持,且有证据表明ESP干预有良好结果。ESP做出的临床决策与医学同事的决策相关性良好,尽管缺乏详细解释ESP决策过程本身以及这一过程发生的影响因素和机制。版权所有© 2016约翰威立国际出版公司。