Lammers Richard, Simunich Thomas, Ashurst John
Duke Lifepoint Conemaugh Memorial Medical Center, Department of Emergency Medicine, Johnstown, Pennsylvania.
Duke Lifepoint Conemaugh Memorial Medical Center, Department of Research, Johnstown, Pennsylvania.
West J Emerg Med. 2016 May;17(3):367-71. doi: 10.5811/westjem.2016.2.29779. Epub 2016 May 5.
With the recent merger of the American Osteopathic Association (AOA) and the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) a heightened pressure for publication may become evident. Our objective was to determine whether there was a gap in the type of both medical degree designation and advanced degree designation among authorship in three United States-based academic emergency medicine journals.
We reviewed the Journal of Emergency Medicine, Academic Emergency Medicine and Annals of Emergency Medicine for the type of degree designation that the first and senior authors had obtained for the years 1995, 2000, 2005, 2010 and 2014.
A total of 2.48% of all authors held a degree in osteopathic medicine. Osteopathic physician first authors contributed to 3.26% of all publications while osteopathic physician senior authors contributed 1.53%. No statistical trend could be established for the years studied for osteopathic physicians. However, we noted an overall trend for increased publication for allopathic senior authors (p=0.001), allopathic first authors with a dual degree (p=0.003) and allopathic senior authors with a dual degree (p=0.005). For each journal studied, no statistical trend could be established for osteopathic first or senior authors but a trend was noted for allopathic first and senior authors in the Journal of Emergency Medicine (p-value=0.020 and 0.006). Of those with dual degrees, osteopathic physicians were in the minority with 1.85% of osteopathic first authors and 0.60% of osteopathic senior authors attaining a dual degree. No statistical trend could be established for increased dual degree publications for osteopathic physicians over the study period, nor could a statistical trend be established for any of the journals studied.
Very few osteopathic physicians have published in the Journal of Emergency Medicine, Academic Emergency Medicine or Annals of Emergency Medicine over the last two decades. Despite a trend for increased publication by allopathic physicians in certain journals, there appears to be no trend for increased publication of osteopathic physicians in emergency medicine.
随着美国骨病协会(AOA)与毕业后医学教育认证委员会(ACGME)最近的合并,发表论文的压力可能会明显增加。我们的目的是确定在美国的三本学术急诊医学期刊的作者中,医学学位类型和高级学位类型是否存在差距。
我们查阅了《急诊医学杂志》《学术急诊医学》和《急诊医学年鉴》,以了解1995年、2000年、2005年、2010年和2014年第一作者和资深作者所获得的学位类型。
所有作者中共有2.48%拥有骨病医学学位。骨病医生作为第一作者的论文占所有发表论文的3.26%,而作为资深作者的占1.53%。在所研究的年份中,骨病医生没有呈现出统计学上的趋势。然而,我们注意到,全科医学资深作者(p = 0.001)、拥有双学位的全科医学第一作者(p = 0.003)和拥有双学位的全科医学资深作者(p = 0.005)的论文发表总体呈上升趋势。对于所研究的每本期刊,骨病医学第一作者或资深作者没有呈现出统计学上的趋势,但在《急诊医学杂志》中,全科医学第一作者和资深作者呈现出一种趋势(p值分别为0.020和0.006)。在拥有双学位的人中,骨病医生占少数,1.85%的骨病医学第一作者和0.60%的骨病医学资深作者获得了双学位。在研究期间,骨病医生双学位论文发表量没有呈现出统计学上的上升趋势,在所研究的任何一本期刊中也没有呈现出统计学上的趋势。
在过去二十年中,很少有骨病医生在《急诊医学杂志》《学术急诊医学》或《急诊医学年鉴》上发表论文。尽管在某些期刊中全科医学医生的论文发表有增加的趋势,但在急诊医学领域,骨病医生的论文发表似乎没有增加的趋势。