Matthews Harold, Penington Tony, Saey Ine, Halliday Jane, Muggli Evelyn, Claes Peter
Murdoch Childrens Research Institute, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.
Royal Children's Hospital, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.
J Anat. 2016 Oct;229(4):549-59. doi: 10.1111/joa.12507. Epub 2016 Jun 23.
Recent advances in the field of geometric morphometrics allow for powerful statistical hypothesis testing for effects of biological and environmental variables on anatomical shape. This study used partial least-squares regression (PLSR) and the recently developed bootstrapped response-based imputation modelling (BRIM) algorithm to test for sexual dimorphism in the craniofacial shape of 1-year-old humans. We observed a recession of the forehead in boys relative to girls, and differences in the nose, consistent with adult dimorphism. Results also suggest that the degree to which individuals express dimorphic traits is continuous throughout the population. This is also seen in adult dimorphism but in 1-year-olds the amount of overlap between groups is much higher, indicating the strength of dimorphism between sexes is lower. Our results demonstrate early sexual dimorphism that is not attributable to the influx of sex hormones at puberty. This highlights the need to look at very early ontogeny for the origins of sexual dimorphism. We suggest that future work look at potential mediating effects of this early dimorphism on the later impact of puberty. The subtle shape differences we have detected, may also be applied to sexing fossilised crania. A common artefact in 3D images of faces of young children is that they often have their mouths open to varying degrees, introducing variability in the data unrelated to anatomy. We describe two PLSR-based methods of correcting this. These methods may facilitate surgical planning and assessment of young children based on 3D images.
几何形态测量学领域的最新进展使得针对生物和环境变量对解剖形状的影响进行强大的统计假设检验成为可能。本研究使用偏最小二乘回归(PLSR)和最近开发的基于自展响应的插补建模(BRIM)算法,来测试1岁人类颅面形状的性别二态性。我们观察到男孩相对于女孩前额后缩,以及鼻子存在差异,这与成年人的二态性一致。结果还表明,个体表现出二态性特征的程度在整个人口中是连续的。这在成年人的二态性中也可见,但在1岁儿童中,群体之间的重叠量要高得多,表明两性之间二态性的强度较低。我们的结果证明了早期的性别二态性并非归因于青春期性激素的涌入。这凸显了从非常早期的个体发育来探寻性别二态性起源的必要性。我们建议未来的研究关注这种早期二态性对青春期后期影响的潜在中介作用。我们检测到的细微形状差异,也可应用于对化石颅骨进行性别鉴定。幼儿面部三维图像中一个常见的伪像就是他们的嘴巴常常不同程度地张开,从而在与解剖结构无关的数据中引入变异性。我们描述了两种基于PLSR的校正方法。这些方法可能有助于基于三维图像对幼儿进行手术规划和评估。