O'Gallagher M K, Lagan M A, Mulholland C P, Parker M, McGinnity G, McLoone E M
Department of Ophthalmology, Eye and Ear Clinic Royal Victoria Hospital, Belfast, UK.
Northern Ireland Clinical Research Support Centre, The Royal Hospitals, Belfast, UK.
Eye (Lond). 2016 Sep;30(9):1215-20. doi: 10.1038/eye.2016.163. Epub 2016 Jul 29.
PurposeThis study aims to evaluate the accuracy of lens prediction formulae on a paediatric population.MethodsA retrospective case-note review was undertaken of patients under 8 years old who underwent cataract surgery with primary lens implantation in a regional referral centre for paediatric ophthalmology, excluding those whose procedure was secondary to trauma. Biometric and refractive data were analysed for 43 eyes, including prediction errors (PE). Statistical measures used included mean absolute error (MAE), median absolute error (MedAE), Student's t-test and Lin's correlation coefficient.ResultsThe mean PE using the SRK-II formula was +0.96 D (range -2.47D to +2.41 D, SD 1.33 D, MAE 1.38 D, MedAE 1.55, n=15). The mean PE was smaller using SRK/T (-0.18 D, range -3.25 D to +3.95 D, SD 1.70 D, MAE 1.30 D, MedAE 1.24, n=27). We performed an analysis of the biometry data using four different formula (Hoffer Q, Holladay 1, SRK-II and SRK/T). Hoffer Q showed a smaller MedAE than other formulae but also a myopic bias.ConclusionOur clinical data suggest SRK/T was more accurate in predicting post-operative refraction in this cohort of paediatric patients undergoing cataract surgery. Hoffer Q may have improved accuracy further.
目的
本研究旨在评估晶状体预测公式在儿科人群中的准确性。
方法
对一家儿科眼科区域转诊中心8岁以下接受白内障手术并植入人工晶状体的患者进行回顾性病例记录审查,不包括那些因外伤而进行手术的患者。分析了43只眼的生物测量和屈光数据,包括预测误差(PE)。使用的统计方法包括平均绝对误差(MAE)、中位数绝对误差(MedAE)、学生t检验和林氏相关系数。
结果
使用SRK-II公式的平均预测误差为+0.96 D(范围为-2.47 D至+2.41 D,标准差1.33 D,MAE 1.38 D,MedAE 1.55,n = 15)。使用SRK/T公式时平均预测误差较小(-0.18 D,范围为-3.25 D至+3.95 D,标准差1.70 D,MAE 1.30 D,MedAE 1.24,n = 27)。我们使用四种不同的公式(霍弗Q公式、霍拉迪1公式、SRK-II公式和SRK/T公式)对生物测量数据进行了分析。霍弗Q公式显示出比其他公式更小的MedAE,但也存在近视偏差。
结论
我们的临床数据表明,SRK/T公式在预测该队列接受白内障手术的儿科患者术后屈光方面更为准确。霍弗Q公式可能会进一步提高准确性。