Scott Michael T, Todd Kimberly E, Oakley Heather, Bradley Julie A, Rotondo Ronny L, Morris Christopher G, Klein Stuart, Mendenhall Nancy P, Indelicato Daniel J
Department of Radiation Oncology, University of Miami Sylvester Comprehensive Cancer Center and Jackson Memorial Hospital, Miami, Florida; Department of Radiation Oncology, University of Florida College of Medicine, Jacksonville, Florida.
Department of Radiation Oncology, University of Florida College of Medicine, Jacksonville, Florida.
Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2016 Oct 1;96(2):401-405. doi: 10.1016/j.ijrobp.2016.06.001. Epub 2016 Jun 5.
To analyze the effectiveness of a certified child life specialist (CCLS) in reducing the frequency of daily anesthesia at our institution, and to quantify the potential health care payer cost savings of CCLS utilization in the United States.
From 2006 to 2014, 738 children (aged ≤21 years) were treated with radiation therapy at our institution. We retrospectively analyzed the frequency of daily anesthesia before and after hiring a CCLS in 2011 after excluding patients aged 0 to 2 and >12 years. In the analyzed cohort of 425 patients the median age was 7.6 years (range, 3-12.9 years). For the pre-CCLS period the overall median age was 7.5 years; for the post-CCLS period the median age was 7.7 years. An average 6-week course of pediatric anesthesia for radiation therapy costs $50,000 in charges to the payer. The average annual cost to employ one CCLS is approximately $50,000.
Before employing a CCLS, 69 of 121 children (57%) aged 3 to 12 years required daily anesthesia, including 33 of 53 children (62.3%) aged 5 to 8 years. After employing a CCLS, 124 of 304 children (40.8%) aged 3 to 12 years required daily anesthesia, including only 34 of 118 children (28.8%) aged 5 to 8 years (P<.0001). With a >16% absolute reduction in anesthesia use after employment of a CCLS, the health care payer cost savings was approaching $50,000 per 6 children aged 3 to 12 years treated annually with radiation therapy in our institution. This reduction resulted in a total of only 6 children aged 3 to 12 years required anesthesia to be treated per year at our center to achieve nearly break-even cost savings to the health care payer if the payer were to subsidize the employment expense of a CCLS. Overall, the CCLS intervention can provide an average annualized health care payer cost savings of "$[(anesthesia cost to payer during radiation therapy course/6) - (CCLS expense to payer/N)]" per child (N) treated with radiation therapy, where N equals the number of children aged 3 to 12 years treated in 1 year. This formula assumes that the payer subsidizes the cost for the employment of a CCLS, although our institution absorbed this expense for this data cohort. The predicted annualized health care system cost savings from reducing the frequency of anesthesia with radiation therapy when treating 100 children aged 3 to 12 years per year could exceed $775,000.
These data suggest that a CCLS significantly reduces the frequency of daily anesthesia for children treated with radiation therapy. Health care system payers may achieve significant cost savings by financially supporting the employment of a CCLS in high-volume pediatric radiation therapy centers.
分析认证儿童生活专家(CCLS)在降低我院每日麻醉频率方面的有效性,并量化在美国使用CCLS可能为医疗保健支付方节省的成本。
2006年至2014年,我院对738名年龄≤21岁的儿童进行了放射治疗。在排除0至2岁和>12岁的患者后,我们回顾性分析了2011年聘用CCLS前后每日麻醉的频率。在分析的425名患者队列中,中位年龄为7.6岁(范围3 - 12.9岁)。CCLS聘用前的总体中位年龄为7.5岁;CCLS聘用后的中位年龄为7.7岁。放射治疗的小儿麻醉平均6周疗程向支付方收取的费用为50,000美元。聘用一名CCLS的年均成本约为50,000美元。
在聘用CCLS之前,121名3至12岁儿童中有69名(57%)需要每日麻醉,其中53名5至8岁儿童中有33名(62.3%)。聘用CCLS后,304名3至12岁儿童中有124名(40.8%)需要每日麻醉,其中118名5至8岁儿童中只有34名(28.8%)(P<0.0001)。聘用CCLS后麻醉使用量绝对减少超过16%,对于我院每年接受放射治疗的每6名3至12岁儿童,医疗保健支付方节省的成本接近50,000美元。这一减少使得我院每年仅6名3至12岁儿童接受治疗时需要麻醉,若支付方补贴CCLS的聘用费用,对医疗保健支付方而言成本节省几乎达到收支平衡。总体而言,CCLS干预可为接受放射治疗的每名儿童(N)平均每年节省医疗保健支付方成本“$[(放射治疗疗程中支付方的麻醉成本/6) - (支付方的CCLS费用/N)]”,其中N等于1年中接受治疗的3至12岁儿童数量。该公式假设支付方补贴CCLS的聘用成本,尽管我院承担了该数据队列的此项费用。预计每年治疗100名3至12岁儿童时,通过减少放射治疗麻醉频率可使医疗保健系统节省成本超过775,000美元。
这些数据表明,CCLS可显著降低接受放射治疗儿童的每日麻醉频率。医疗保健系统支付方通过在高流量小儿放射治疗中心资助聘用CCLS,可能实现显著的成本节省。