Salchow Christina, Strohmeier Daniel, Klee Sascha, Jannek Dunja, Schiecke Karin, Witte Herbert, Nehorai Arye, Haueisen Jens
Institute of Biomedical Engineering and Informatics, Technische Universität Ilmenau Ilmenau, Germany.
Institute of Medical Statistics, Computer Sciences and Documentation, Jena University Hospital, Friedrich Schiller University Jena Jena, Germany.
Front Hum Neurosci. 2016 Aug 18;10:413. doi: 10.3389/fnhum.2016.00413. eCollection 2016.
A controversy exists on photic driving in the human visual cortex evoked by intermittent photic stimulation. Frequency entrainment and resonance phenomena are reported for frequencies higher than 12 Hz in some studies while missing in others. We hypothesized that this might be due to different experimental conditions, since both high and low intensity light stimulation were used. However, most studies do not report radiometric measurements, which makes it impossible to categorize the stimulation according to photopic, mesopic, and scotopic vision. Low intensity light stimulation might lead to scotopic vision, where rod perception dominates. In this study, we investigated photic driving for rod-dominated visual input under scotopic conditions. Twelve healthy volunteers were stimulated with low intensity light flashes at 20 stimulation frequencies, leading to rod activation only. The frequencies were multiples of the individual alpha frequency (α) of each volunteer in the range from 0.40 to 2.30(∗)α. Three hundred and six-channel whole head magnetoencephalography recordings were analyzed in time, frequency, and spatiotemporal domains with the Topographic Matching Pursuit algorithm. We found resonance phenomena and frequency entrainment for stimulations at or close to the individual alpha frequency (0.90-1.10(∗)α) and half of the alpha frequency (0.40-0.55(∗)α). No signs of resonance and frequency entrainment phenomena were revealed around 2.00(∗)α. Instead, on-responses at the beginning and off-responses at the end of each stimulation train were observed for the first time in a photic driving experiment at frequencies of 1.30-2.30(∗)α, indicating that the flicker fusion threshold was reached. All results, the resonance and entrainment as well as the fusion effects, provide evidence for rod-dominated photic driving in the visual cortex.
关于间歇性光刺激诱发的人类视觉皮层光驱动存在争议。在一些研究中,报告了频率高于12Hz时的频率夹带和共振现象,而在其他研究中则未发现。我们推测这可能是由于实验条件不同,因为使用了高强度和低强度光刺激。然而,大多数研究没有报告辐射测量结果,这使得无法根据明视觉、中间视觉和暗视觉对刺激进行分类。低强度光刺激可能导致暗视觉,其中视杆细胞感知占主导。在本研究中,我们研究了暗视觉条件下视杆细胞主导的视觉输入的光驱动。12名健康志愿者在20个刺激频率下接受低强度光闪光刺激,仅导致视杆细胞激活。这些频率是每个志愿者个体α频率(α)的倍数,范围为0.40至2.30(∗)α。使用地形匹配追踪算法在时间、频率和时空域对306通道全头磁脑电图记录进行了分析。我们发现,在个体α频率(0.90 - 1.10(∗)α)或接近该频率以及α频率的一半(0.40 - 0.55(∗)α)时的刺激存在共振现象和频率夹带。在2.00(∗)α左右未发现共振和频率夹带现象的迹象。相反,在1.30 - 2.30(∗)α频率的光驱动实验中首次观察到每个刺激序列开始时的开启反应和结束时的关闭反应,表明达到了闪烁融合阈值。所有结果,包括共振、夹带以及融合效应,都为视觉皮层中视杆细胞主导的光驱动提供了证据。