Reeves Scott, Pelone Ferruccio, Hendry Julie, Lock Nicholas, Marshall Jayne, Pillay Leontia, Wood Ruth
a Faculty of Health, Social Care and Education , Kingston University and St George's, University of London , London , UK.
Med Teach. 2016 Dec;38(12):1221-1228. doi: 10.1080/0142159X.2016.1210114. Epub 2016 Sep 27.
Interprofessional facilitators and teachers are regarded as central to the effective delivery of interprofessional education (IPE). As the IPE literature continues to expand, most studies have focused on reporting learner outcomes, with little attention paid to IPE facilitation. However, a number of studies have recently emerged reporting on this phenomenon.
To present a synthesis of qualitative evidence on the facilitation of IPE, using a meta-ethnographic approach.
Electronic databases and journals were searched for the past 10 years. Of the 2164 abstracts initially found, 94 full papers were reviewed and subsequently 12 papers were included. Teams of two reviewers independently completed each step in the review process. The quality of these papers was assessed using a modified critical appraisal checklist.
Seven key concepts embedded in the included studies were synthesized into three main factors which provided an insight into the nature of IPE facilitation. Specifically, the synthesis found that IPE facilitation is influenced by "contextual characteristics"; "facilitator experiences"; and the "use of different facilitation strategies".
IPE facilitation is a complex activity affected by contextual, experiential and pedagogical factors. Further research is needed to explore the effects of these factors on the delivery of IPE.
跨专业促进者和教师被视为有效开展跨专业教育(IPE)的核心。随着IPE文献不断增多,大多数研究都集中在报告学习者的成果上,而对IPE促进方面关注甚少。然而,最近出现了一些关于这一现象的研究。
采用元民族志方法,对关于IPE促进的定性证据进行综合分析。
检索过去10年的电子数据库和期刊。在最初找到的2164篇摘要中,对94篇全文进行了评审,随后纳入了12篇论文。由两名评审员组成的团队独立完成评审过程的每一步。使用修改后的批判性评估清单对这些论文的质量进行评估。
纳入研究中蕴含的七个关键概念被综合为三个主要因素,这为深入了解IPE促进的本质提供了依据。具体而言,综合分析发现,IPE促进受到“情境特征”、“促进者经验”和“不同促进策略的使用”的影响。
IPE促进是一项受情境、经验和教学因素影响的复杂活动。需要进一步研究来探讨这些因素对IPE实施的影响。