Florey Institute of Neuroscience and Mental Health, University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Australia
School of Health Sciences, University of South Australia, Adelaide, Australia.
Int J Stroke. 2016 Dec;11(9):968-977. doi: 10.1177/1747493016669861. Epub 2016 Oct 4.
Fatigue is a common and debilitating symptom after stroke. The last decade has seen rapid expansion of the research literature on post-stroke fatigue, but prevalence remains unclear.
To estimate post-stroke fatigue prevalence and to identify the contributing factors to fatigue, by conducting a systematic review and meta-analysis.
We included all studies of adult stroke survivors that used a recognized assessment scale for fatigue (search date September 2014). Two reviewers independently reviewed all full texts for inclusion. Data were extracted by one reviewer and independently cross-checked by a second. Risk of bias was evaluated using a critical appraisal tool. From an overall yield of 921 studies, 101 full text papers were screened, and 49 of these met inclusion criteria. The most widely used measure of fatigue was the Fatigue Severity Scale (n = 24 studies). Prevalence estimates at a cut-off score of > or ≥ 4 were available for 22 of these 24 studies (total n = 3491), and ranged from 25 to 85%. In random effects meta-analysis, the pooled prevalence estimate was 50% (95% CI 43-57%), with substantial heterogeneity (I = 94%). Neither depression status nor time point post-stroke explained the heterogeneity between studies. In post-hoc analysis, fatigue prevalence was found to be lower in the four Asian studies (35%; 95% CI 20-50; I = 96%).
Our results confirm that fatigue is a widespread issue for stroke survivors, although it may be less prevalent in Asia. Further research is needed to explain the wide variability in prevalence estimates between studies.
疲劳是中风后常见且使人虚弱的症状。过去十年中风后疲劳的研究文献迅速增加,但患病率仍不清楚。
通过系统评价和荟萃分析来评估中风后疲劳的患病率,并确定导致疲劳的因素。
我们纳入了所有使用公认的疲劳评估量表评估成年中风幸存者的研究(检索日期为 2014 年 9 月)。两位审查员独立审查所有全文以确定纳入标准。一位审查员提取数据,另一位独立交叉核对。使用批判性评价工具评估偏倚风险。从总共 921 项研究中,有 101 篇全文论文进行了筛选,其中 49 篇符合纳入标准。使用最广泛的疲劳评估量表是疲劳严重程度量表(n=24 项研究)。其中 24 项研究中的 22 项(共 n=3491 人)提供了疲劳严重程度评分>4 或≥4 的患病率估计值,范围从 25%到 85%。在随机效应荟萃分析中,汇总的患病率估计值为 50%(95%CI 43-57%),异质性很大(I=94%)。抑郁状态和中风后时间点都不能解释研究间的异质性。在事后分析中,发现四项亚洲研究中的疲劳患病率较低(35%;95%CI 20-50%;I=96%)。
我们的结果证实,疲劳是中风幸存者普遍存在的问题,尽管在亚洲,疲劳的患病率可能较低。需要进一步研究来解释研究间患病率估计值的巨大差异。