Leite Raphael B C, Mota-Rolim Sergio A, Queiroz Claudio M T
Brain Institute, Federal University of Rio Grande do Norte Natal, Brazil.
Front Neurosci. 2016 Oct 13;10:447. doi: 10.3389/fnins.2016.00447. eCollection 2016.
Absolute pitch (AP) is the ability to identify and name the pitch of a sound without external reference. Often, accuracy and speed at naming isolated musical pitches are correlated with demographic, biological, and acoustical parameters to gain insight into the genesis and evolution of this ability in specific cohorts. However, the majority of those studies were conducted in North America, Europe, or Asia. To fill this gap, here we investigated the pitch-naming performance in a large population of Brazilian conservatory musicians ( = 200). As previously shown, we found that the population performance was rather a continuum than an "" ability. By comparing the observed distribution of correct responses to a theoretical binomial distribution, we estimated the prevalence of AP as being 18% amongst regular music students. High accuracy thresholds (e.g., 85% of correct responses) yielded a prevalence of 4%, suggesting that AP might have been underestimated in previous reports. Irrespective of the threshold used, AP prevalence was higher in musicians who started their musical practice and formal musical education early in life. Finally, we compared the performance of those music students (average proficiency group) with another group of students selected to take part in the conservatory orchestra (high proficiency group, = 30). Interestingly, the prevalence of AP was higher in the latter in comparison to the former group. In addition, even when the response was incorrect, the mean absolute deviation from the correct response was smaller in the high proficiency group compared to the average proficiency group (Glass's Δ: 0.5). Taken together, our results show that the prevalence of AP in Brazilian students is similar to other non-tonal language populations, although this measure is highly dependent on the scoring threshold used. Despite corroborating that early involvement with musical practice and formal education can foster AP ability, the present data suggest that music proficiency may also play an important role in AP expression.
绝对音高(AP)是指在没有外部参照的情况下识别和说出声音音高的能力。通常,孤立音乐音高命名的准确性和速度与人口统计学、生物学和声学参数相关,以便深入了解特定群体中这种能力的起源和演变。然而,这些研究大多是在北美、欧洲或亚洲进行的。为了填补这一空白,我们在此调查了大量巴西音乐学院学生(n = 200)的音高命名表现。如先前所示,我们发现群体表现更像是一个连续体,而非一种“全或无”的能力。通过将观察到的正确反应分布与理论二项分布进行比较,我们估计在正规音乐学生中绝对音高的患病率为18%。高精度阈值(例如,85%的正确反应)得出的患病率为4%,这表明在先前的报告中绝对音高可能被低估了。无论使用何种阈值,在早年开始音乐练习和接受正规音乐教育的音乐家中,绝对音高的患病率更高。最后,我们将这些音乐学生(平均水平组)的表现与另一组被选入音乐学院管弦乐队的学生(高水平组,n = 30)进行了比较。有趣的是,与前一组相比,后一组中绝对音高的患病率更高。此外,即使反应不正确,高水平组与平均水平组相比,与正确反应的平均绝对偏差也更小(格拉斯Δ:0.5)。综上所述,我们的结果表明,巴西学生中绝对音高的患病率与其他非声调语言群体相似,尽管这一测量高度依赖于所使用的评分阈值。尽管证实早期参与音乐练习和正规教育可以培养绝对音高能力,但目前的数据表明音乐水平在绝对音高的表现中也可能起着重要作用。