Verger Pierre, Collange Fanny, Fressard Lisa, Bocquier Aurélie, Gautier Arnaud, Pulcini Céline, Raude Jocelyn, Peretti-Watel Patrick
INSERM, UMR912 'Economics and Social Sciences Applied to Health and Analysis of Medical Information' (SESSTIM), Marseille, France.
ORS PACA, South-eastern Health Regional Observatory, Marseille, France.
Euro Surveill. 2016 Nov 24;21(47). doi: 10.2807/1560-7917.ES.2016.21.47.30406.
This article sought to estimate the prevalence of vaccine hesitancy (VH) among French general practitioners (GPs) and to study its demographic, professional and personal correlates. We conducted a cross-sectional telephone survey about GPs' vaccination-related attitudes and practices in 2014 in a national panel of 1,712 GPs in private practice, randomly selected from an exhaustive database of health professionals in France. A cluster analysis of various dimensions of VH (self-reported vaccine recommendations, perceptions of vaccine risks and usefulness) identified three clusters: 86% of GPs (95% confidence interval (CI): 84-88) were not or only slightly vaccine-hesitant, 11% (95% CI: 9-12) moderately hesitant and 3% (95% CI: 3-4) highly hesitant or opposed to vaccination. GPs in the latter two clusters were less frequently vaccinated and reported occasional practice of alternative medicine more often than those in the first cluster; they also described less experience with vaccine-preventable diseases and more experience with patients who they considered had serious adverse effects from vaccination. This study confirms the presence of VH among French GPs but also suggests that its prevalence is moderate. Given GPs' central role in vaccination, these results nevertheless call for a mobilisation of stakeholders to address VH among GPs.
本文旨在估算法国全科医生(GP)中疫苗犹豫(VH)的流行情况,并研究其人口统计学、职业和个人相关因素。2014年,我们对法国1712名私人执业全科医生组成的全国性样本进行了一项横断面电话调查,这些医生是从法国详尽的卫生专业人员数据库中随机抽取的,调查内容涉及他们与疫苗接种相关的态度和做法。对VH的各个维度(自我报告的疫苗推荐、对疫苗风险和效用的认知)进行聚类分析,确定了三个类别:86%的全科医生(95%置信区间(CI):84 - 88)不存在或仅有轻微的疫苗犹豫,11%(95%CI:9 - 12)中度犹豫,3%(95%CI:3 - 4)高度犹豫或反对疫苗接种。后两个类别的全科医生接种疫苗的频率较低,与第一类相比,更常报告偶尔采用替代医学疗法;他们还表示对疫苗可预防疾病的经验较少,而对他们认为因接种疫苗出现严重不良反应的患者的经验较多。这项研究证实了法国全科医生中存在VH,但也表明其流行程度为中等。鉴于全科医生在疫苗接种中的核心作用,这些结果仍呼吁各利益相关方动员起来解决全科医生中的VH问题。