Koda Masao, Mannoji Chikato, Murakami Masazumi, Kinoshita Tomoaki, Hirayama Jiro, Miyashita Tomohiro, Eguchi Yawara, Yamazaki Masashi, Suzuki Takane, Aramomi Masaaki, Ota Mitsutoshi, Maki Satoshi, Takahashi Kazuhisa, Furuya Takeo
Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Chiba University Graduate School of Medicine, Chiba, Japan.; Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Chiba Aoba Municipal Hospital, Chiba, Japan.
Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Chiba Aoba Municipal Hospital, Chiba, Japan.
Asian Spine J. 2016 Dec;10(6):1085-1090. doi: 10.4184/asj.2016.10.6.1085. Epub 2016 Dec 8.
Retrospective case-control study.
To determine whether kissing spine is a risk factor for recurrence of sciatica after lumbar posterior decompression using a spinous process floating approach.
Kissing spine is defined by apposition and sclerotic change of the facing spinous processes as shown in X-ray images, and is often accompanied by marked disc degeneration and decrement of disc height. If kissing spine significantly contributes to weight bearing and the stability of the lumbar spine, trauma to the spinous process might induce a breakdown of lumbar spine stability after posterior decompression surgery in cases of kissing spine.
The present study included 161 patients who had undergone posterior decompression surgery for lumbar canal stenosis using a spinous process floating approaches. We defined recurrence of sciatica as that resolved after initial surgery and then recurred. Kissing spine was defined as sclerotic change and the apposition of the spinous process in a plain radiogram. Preoperative foraminal stenosis was determined by the decrease of perineural fat intensity detected by parasagittal T1-weighted magnetic resonance imaging. Preoperative percentage slip, segmental range of motion, and segmental scoliosis were analyzed in preoperative radiographs. Univariate analysis followed by stepwise logistic regression analysis determined factors independently associated with recurrence of sciatica.
Stepwise logistic regression revealed kissing spine (=0.024; odds ratio, 3.80) and foraminal stenosis (<0.01; odds ratio, 17.89) as independent risk factors for the recurrence of sciatica after posterior lumbar spinal decompression with spinous process floating procedures for lumbar spinal canal stenosis.
When a patient shows kissing spine and concomitant subclinical foraminal stenosis at the affected level, we should sufficiently discuss the selection of an appropriate surgical procedure.
回顾性病例对照研究。
采用棘突漂浮法确定腰椎后路减压术后吻棘是否为坐骨神经痛复发的危险因素。
吻棘在X线片上表现为相邻棘突的并置和硬化改变,常伴有明显的椎间盘退变和椎间盘高度降低。如果吻棘对腰椎的负重和稳定性有显著影响,那么在吻棘病例中,棘突创伤可能会导致后路减压手术后腰椎稳定性的破坏。
本研究纳入了161例行棘突漂浮法腰椎管狭窄后路减压手术的患者。我们将坐骨神经痛复发定义为初次手术后缓解然后复发。吻棘定义为平片上棘突的硬化改变和并置。术前椎间孔狭窄通过矢状旁位T1加权磁共振成像检测到的神经周围脂肪强度降低来确定。术前X线片分析术前滑脱百分比、节段活动范围和节段性脊柱侧凸。单因素分析后进行逐步逻辑回归分析,确定与坐骨神经痛复发独立相关的因素。
逐步逻辑回归显示,吻棘(P=0.024;比值比,3.80)和椎间孔狭窄(P<0.01;比值比,17.89)是腰椎管狭窄症采用棘突漂浮法行腰椎后路减压术后坐骨神经痛复发的独立危险因素。
当患者在受累节段出现吻棘并伴有亚临床椎间孔狭窄时,我们应充分讨论合适手术方式的选择。