Atchley Paul, Tran Ashleigh V, Salehinejad Mohammad Ali
University of Kansas, Department of Psychology, USA.
University of Kansas, Department of Psychology, USA.
Accid Anal Prev. 2017 Feb;99(Pt A):306-311. doi: 10.1016/j.aap.2016.12.005. Epub 2016 Dec 23.
The goal of the current work was to create a publicly available visualization tool of distracted driving research, the purpose of which is to allow the public and other stakeholders to empirically inform questions of their choice that may bear on policy discussions.
Fifty years of distracted driving research was used to design a comprehensive database of studies that evaluated the effects of distraction on driving performance. Distraction sources (e.g., texting, talking, visual distraction) and performance measures were defined, and the sample of studies were evaluated and categorized by their measures.
The final product yielded 342 studies using various methodologies. Across all measures, 1297 found distractions degraded driving performance, 54 found distraction improved driving performance, and 257 found distraction had no effect on driving performance. An analysis of the most common phone distractions (texting and talking) showed that texting almost always results in degraded performance. Aggregate data reveal no difference in performance decrements for hand-held or hands-free phones even though single studies of those variables vary in their outcomes.
This project illustrates how scientific research can be made publically available for use by a diverse audience of stakeholders. An important result of this project is that data aggregated along a simple set of characteristics such as whether or not performance is decreased, improved or not affected, can reveal trends in the data that are less clear from any individual study.
当前工作的目标是创建一个可供公众使用的分心驾驶研究可视化工具,其目的是让公众和其他利益相关者能够根据实证为他们所选择的、可能与政策讨论相关的问题提供信息。
利用五十年的分心驾驶研究来设计一个全面的研究数据库,该数据库评估分心对驾驶性能的影响。定义了分心源(如发短信、交谈、视觉分心)和性能指标,并根据其指标对研究样本进行评估和分类。
最终成果产生了342项采用各种方法的研究。在所有指标中,1297项研究发现分心会降低驾驶性能,54项研究发现分心会提高驾驶性能,257项研究发现分心对驾驶性能没有影响。对最常见的手机分心行为(发短信和交谈)的分析表明,发短信几乎总会导致性能下降。汇总数据显示,手持手机或免提手机在性能下降方面没有差异,尽管对这些变量的单项研究结果各不相同。
该项目说明了如何使科学研究可供不同的利益相关者群体公开使用。该项目的一个重要成果是,按照一组简单的特征(如性能是否下降、提高或不受影响)汇总的数据,可以揭示从任何单项研究中不太明显的数据趋势。