Cohen Tamara R, Hazell Tom J, Vanstone Catherine A, Rodd Celia, Weiler Hope A
School of Dietetics and Human Nutrition, Macdonald Campus, McGill University.
Can J Public Health. 2016 Dec 27;107(4-5):e453-e460. doi: 10.17269/cjph.107.5470.
Childhood obesity interventions should be family-centered and focused on lifestyle behaviours that achieve sustainable reductions in adiposity. The primary objective of this randomized controlled trial was to test a family-centered lifestyle intervention using Canada's Food and Physical Activity (PA) Guidelines to reduce body mass index-for-age z-scores (BAZ) in overweight and obese (OW/OB) children.
Children (n = 78; ages 6-8.5 years) were randomized to standard (StnTx) or modified (ModTx) interventions or control (Ctrl). Measurements at baseline and every three months for one year included: anthropometry, BAZ, waist circumference (WC), and dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry scans for percent body fat (%BF), fat mass (FM) and trunk fat mass. Fatty acids measured by gas chromatography were used to assess compliance to the milk and alternatives interventions during the first six months. Six intervention sessions were based on Canada's Food and PA Guidelines and individualized to meet the needs of the family. ModTx were advised to consume four milk and alternatives/day versus the recommended two (StnTx) and to preferentially engage in daily weight-bearing PA. Ctrl were provided the guidelines.
Baseline anthropometry did not differ among groups. At 12 months (n = 73), all groups increased height (p < 0.001) and lean mass (p < 0.001). ModTx decreased BAZ (p < 0.001); %BF decreased in ModTx (p = 0.018), but not in StnTx (p = 0.997) or Ctrl (p = 0.998). FM, WC and trunk fat mass all significantly increased in Ctrl (p < 0.001). At baseline and three months, fatty acids did not differ among groups, however they did decrease in ModTx at six months [C14:0 (-0.07%, p = 0.053), C15:0 (-0.04%, p = 0.049), C17:0 (-0.09%, p = 0.036)].
Participating in a family centered-lifestyle intervention that focused on Canadian dietary and PA Guidelines and emphasized increasing milk and alternatives and weight-bearing PA had positive effects on reducing adiposity in OW/OB children. Guidelines are appropriate for the obese pediatric population but need to be individualized to meet the needs of the family. Additional studies are warranted to test the use of biochemical indices to assess compliance to milk and alternative intakes in OW/OB children participating in lifestyle interventions.
儿童肥胖干预应以家庭为中心,并侧重于能实现肥胖程度可持续降低的生活方式行为。这项随机对照试验的主要目的是测试一种以家庭为中心的生活方式干预措施,该措施采用加拿大的饮食和身体活动(PA)指南,以降低超重和肥胖(OW/OB)儿童的年龄别体重指数z评分(BAZ)。
将儿童(n = 78;年龄6 - 8.5岁)随机分为标准干预组(StnTx)、改良干预组(ModTx)或对照组(Ctrl)。在基线时以及之后一年中每三个月进行一次测量,包括:人体测量、BAZ、腰围(WC),以及通过双能X线吸收法扫描测量体脂百分比(%BF)、脂肪量(FM)和躯干脂肪量。在前六个月,通过气相色谱法测量的脂肪酸用于评估对奶类及替代食物干预措施的依从性。六个干预环节基于加拿大的饮食和PA指南,并根据家庭需求进行个性化调整。建议改良干预组每天食用四份奶类及替代食物,而标准干预组为推荐的两份,并优先进行每日负重PA。对照组则提供指南。
各小组的基线人体测量数据无差异。在12个月时(n = 73),所有组的身高(p < 0.001)和去脂体重(p < 0.001)均增加。改良干预组的BAZ降低(p < 0.001);改良干预组的%BF降低(p = 0.018),但标准干预组(p = 0.997)和对照组(p = 0.998)未降低。对照组的FM、WC和躯干脂肪量均显著增加(p < 0.001)。在基线和三个月时,各小组的脂肪酸无差异,但在六个月时改良干预组的脂肪酸有所降低[C14:0(-0.07%,p = 0.053),C15:0(-0.04%,p = 0.049),C17:0(-0.09%,p = 0.036)]。
参与一项以家庭为中心的生活方式干预,该干预以加拿大饮食和PA指南为重点,强调增加奶类及替代食物和负重PA,对降低OW/OB儿童的肥胖程度有积极影响。指南适用于肥胖儿童群体,但需要根据家庭需求进行个性化调整。有必要开展更多研究,以测试使用生化指标评估参与生活方式干预的OW/OB儿童对奶类及替代食物摄入量的依从性。