Département de Science Politique, Université Laval, Québec, Qc, Canada and INRS-UCS, Montreal, QC, Canada.
Institut National de Recherche Scientifique, Centre Urbanisation Culture et Société, Montreal, QC, Canada.
Eur J Public Health. 2017 Aug 1;27(4):599-604. doi: 10.1093/eurpub/ckw245.
Several studies have shown that an individual's state of health can significantly affect their decision to vote, but analysis is often only done on a single level of government; the national level. However, prior research has shown that the determining factors for voting can differ according to the level of government being considered. Our analysis is the first attempt to take a comprehensive look at the magnitude of health and political participation in a same country on different levels.
Based on Canadian General Social Survey-Social Identity (2013; N = 27 695), we examined both the direct and indirect effect of self-rated health and self-rated mental health on (1) national voter turnout; (2) local voter turnout and (3) other forms of political participation.
The results show that health has a different effect on turnout depending the level of government. While health certainly affects participation on both levels of government, general health significantly affects national electoral participation levels while mental health more significantly affects electoral participation on the municipal level. Additionally, people who consider their mental health to be poorer, are more likely to sign an online petition.
These elements highlight the necessity of questioning the cost of voting according to the level of government, and that further research into the potential offered by Internet and remote voting, is worthwhile-despite the opinions of critics who eschew these means of voting.
多项研究表明,个人的健康状况会显著影响其投票决策,但分析往往仅在单一政府层面进行,即国家层面。然而,先前的研究表明,投票的决定因素可能因所考虑的政府层级而异。我们的分析首次尝试全面考察同一国家不同层级的健康状况和政治参与程度。
基于加拿大综合社会调查-社会认同(2013 年;N=27695),我们考察了自评健康和自评心理健康对(1)全国投票率;(2)地方投票率和(3)其他形式的政治参与的直接和间接影响。
结果表明,健康对不同层级政府的投票率有不同的影响。虽然健康对两个政府层级的参与都有影响,但总体健康状况显著影响国家选举参与水平,而心理健康状况更显著影响市级选举参与。此外,认为自己心理健康状况较差的人更有可能签署在线请愿书。
这些因素突出了根据政府层级质疑投票成本的必要性,并且值得进一步研究互联网和远程投票所提供的潜力,尽管批评者对这些投票方式持回避态度。