Söderlund Peter, Rapeli Lauri
Åbo Akademi University.
University of Helsinki.
Politics Life Sci. 2015 Spring;34(1):28-43. doi: 10.1017/pls.2015.3.
In search of a better understanding of inequalities in citizen political engagement, scholars have begun addressing the relationship between personal health and patterns of political behavior. This study focuses on the impact of personal health on various forms of political participation. The analysis contributes to existing knowledge by examining a number of different participation forms beyond just voting. Using European Social Survey data from 2012/2013 for Denmark, Finland, Iceland, Norway and Sweden (N = 8,060), self-reported turnout and six alternative modes of political engagement were modeled as dependent variables. Contrary to expectations, poor health did not depress participation across all forms. As assumed by the increased activism hypothesis, all else equal, people with poor health were more active than their healthy counterparts in direct contacts with power holders and demonstrations. The results reveal a "reversed health gap" by showing that people with health problems are in fact more politically active than what previous research, which has focused on voting, has suggested. Although the magnitude of the gap should not be overdramatized, our results stress the importance of distinguishing between different forms of participation when analyzing the impact of health on political engagement. Nevertheless, the findings show that poor health can stimulate people into political engagement rather than depressing activity. This finding holds when the effects of several sociodemographic and motivational factors are controlled for.
为了更好地理解公民政治参与中的不平等现象,学者们开始探讨个人健康与政治行为模式之间的关系。本研究聚焦于个人健康对各种政治参与形式的影响。该分析通过考察除投票之外的多种不同参与形式,为现有知识做出了贡献。利用2012/2013年丹麦、芬兰、冰岛、挪威和瑞典的欧洲社会调查数据(N = 8060),将自我报告的投票率和六种替代性政治参与模式作为因变量进行建模。与预期相反,健康状况不佳并未抑制所有形式的参与。正如激进行动主义假设所假定的,在其他条件相同的情况下,健康状况不佳的人在与掌权者的直接接触和示威活动中比健康的同龄人更为活跃。结果显示出一种“反向健康差距”,即有健康问题的人实际上在政治上比以往专注于投票的研究所表明的更为活跃。尽管这种差距的程度不应被过度夸大,但我们的结果强调了在分析健康对政治参与的影响时区分不同参与形式的重要性。然而,研究结果表明,健康状况不佳会促使人们参与政治,而不是抑制其活动。当控制了几个社会人口统计学和动机因素的影响时,这一发现依然成立。