Neel J V, Rothman E D
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 1978 Nov;75(11):5585-8. doi: 10.1073/pnas.75.11.5585.
Three different formulations have been used to estimate the average rate/locus/generation with which mutation results in electrophoretically detectable variants of 28 proteins in 12 tribal Amerindian populations. All methods are indirect--i.e., they assume a reasonable approximation to equilibrium between mutation and loss of mutants from the population--and are based on the further assumption that the biochemical traits under consideration are essentially neutral in their phenotypic effects. Despite the fact that the methods draw on somewhat different aspects of the available data, there is satisfactory agreement between them, the average of the three estimates being 1.6 X 10(-5)/locus/generation. This average does not encompass mutation that does not result in a change in electrophoretic mobility or that results in loss of enzyme activity. It is noteworthy that this estimate is in satisfactory agreement with a recent estimate by Neel and Thompson [Neel, J. V. & Thompson, E. A. (1978) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 75, 1904--1908] of the mutation pressure necessary to maintain the number of "private" genetic polymorphisms being encountered in Amerindian tribes, if selection is not a factor.
三种不同的方法被用于估计在12个美洲印第安部落群体中,突变产生28种蛋白质的电泳可检测变体的平均速率/位点/世代。所有方法都是间接的——也就是说,它们假定在突变和群体中突变体的丢失之间达到平衡的合理近似值——并且基于进一步的假设,即所考虑的生化性状在其表型效应上基本是中性的。尽管这些方法利用了可用数据的不同方面,但它们之间存在令人满意的一致性,三个估计值的平均值为1.6×10⁻⁵/位点/世代。这个平均值不包括不会导致电泳迁移率变化或导致酶活性丧失的突变。值得注意的是,这个估计值与Neel和Thompson [Neel, J. V. & Thompson, E. A. (1978) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 75, 1904--1908] 最近的估计值令人满意地一致,如果选择不是一个因素,该估计值是维持在美洲印第安部落中遇到的“私人”遗传多态性数量所需的突变压力。