O Elansary Hosam, Ashfaq Muhammad, Ali Hayssam M, Yessoufou Kowiyou
Floriculture, Ornamental Horticulture and Garden Design Department, Faculty of Agriculture (El-Shatby), Alexandria University, Alexandria, Egypt.
Biodiversity Institute of Ontario, University of Guelph, ON, Guelph, Canada.
PLoS One. 2017 Feb 15;12(2):e0172170. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0172170. eCollection 2017.
DNA barcoding relies on short and standardized gene regions to identify species. The agricultural and horticultural applications of barcoding such as for marketplace regulation and copyright protection remain poorly explored. This study examines the effectiveness of the standard plant barcode markers (matK and rbcL) for the identification of plant species in private and public nurseries in northern Egypt. These two markers were sequenced from 225 specimens of 161 species and 62 plant families of horticultural importance. The sequence recovery was similar for rbcL (96.4%) and matK (84%), but the number of specimens assigned correctly to the respective genera and species was lower for rbcL (75% and 29%) than matK (85% and 40%). The combination of rbcL and matK brought the number of correct generic and species assignments to 83.4% and 40%, respectively. Individually, the efficiency of both markers varied among different plant families; for example, all palm specimens (Arecaceae) were correctly assigned to species while only one individual of Asteraceae was correctly assigned to species. Further, barcodes reliably assigned ornamental horticultural and medicinal plants correctly to genus while they showed a lower or no success in assigning these plants to species and cultivars. For future, we recommend the combination of a complementary barcode (e.g. ITS or trnH-psbA) with rbcL + matK to increase the performance of taxa identification. By aiding species identification of horticultural crops and ornamental palms, the analysis of the barcode regions will have large impact on horticultural industry.
DNA条形码技术依靠短的标准化基因区域来识别物种。条形码技术在农业和园艺领域的应用,如市场监管和版权保护,仍未得到充分探索。本研究考察了标准植物条形码标记(matK和rbcL)在埃及北部公私苗圃中识别植物物种的有效性。从161个物种、62个具有园艺重要性的植物科的225个标本中对这两个标记进行了测序。rbcL(96.4%)和matK(84%)的序列回收率相似,但rbcL正确归属于相应属和种的标本数量(75%和29%)低于matK(85%和40%)。rbcL和matK的组合使正确的属和种归属数量分别达到83.4%和40%。单独来看,这两个标记的效率在不同植物科之间有所不同;例如,所有棕榈标本(棕榈科)都能正确归为物种,而菊科中只有一个个体能正确归为物种。此外,条形码能可靠地将观赏园艺植物和药用植物正确归为属,但在将这些植物归为种和品种方面成功率较低或没有成功。未来,我们建议将互补条形码(如ITS或trnH-psbA)与rbcL + matK结合使用,以提高分类群识别的性能。通过辅助园艺作物和观赏棕榈的物种识别,条形码区域分析将对园艺产业产生重大影响。