Tolhurst Edward, Weicht Bernhard
School of Social Work, Allied and Public Health, Staffordshire University, Blackheath Lane, Stafford ST18 0AD, United Kingdom.
Department of Sociology, University of Innsbruck, Innrain 52, A-6020 Innsbruck, Austria.
J Aging Stud. 2017 Jan;40:29-35. doi: 10.1016/j.jaging.2016.12.005. Epub 2017 Jan 2.
An understanding of dementia requires sensitivity to the complex breadth of factors that comprise the person's experiential and social context. This is necessary to ensure that academic and public perspectives on dementia are not subsumed under homogenising discourses that prioritise the neurodegenerative basis of the condition. Gender is one such factor of this 'social location' that must be acknowledged. Cultural standards of masculinity have particular impacts upon men with the condition, thus generating distinctive challenges. This article draws upon qualitative research that included joint interviews with 14 men with dementia and their carers. The analytical focus is on the perspectives of the men with dementia and the strategies with which they respond to the condition. These perspectives are organised via four themes: remaining unmoved, fighting back, emphasising social contributions, and redefining services. This enables exploration of how men adopt particular strategies to preserve their own personhood, which include equable resilience, but also more agential measures to counter the influence of the condition. It is concluded that an approach to dementia research that is more sensitive to masculine-gendered experience is required so that the experience of men with the condition can be conveyed more cogently.
对痴呆症的理解需要敏锐地感知构成个人体验和社会背景的复杂多样的因素。这对于确保学术界和公众对痴呆症的看法不会被纳入那些优先考虑该病症神经退行性基础的同质化话语之中是必要的。性别就是这种“社会定位”中必须被承认的一个因素。男性气质的文化标准对患有痴呆症的男性有特殊影响,从而产生独特的挑战。本文借鉴了定性研究,其中包括对14名患有痴呆症的男性及其照料者进行的联合访谈。分析重点在于患有痴呆症的男性的观点以及他们应对该病症的策略。这些观点通过四个主题进行组织:不为所动、反击、强调社会贡献以及重新定义服务。这有助于探究男性如何采取特定策略来维护自己的人格,其中包括平和的适应力,也包括更具能动性的措施来对抗病症的影响。研究得出结论,需要一种对男性性别体验更敏感的痴呆症研究方法,以便更有说服力地传达患有该病症男性的经历。