Lutes Lesley D, Damschroder Laura J, Masheb Robin, Kim Hyungjin Myra, Gillon Leah, Holleman Robert G, Goodrich David E, Lowery Julie C, Janney Carol, Kirsh Susan, Richardson Caroline R
Department of Psychology, University of British Columbia, 3187 University Way, Kelowna, BC, V1V 1V7, Canada.
VA Center for Clinical Management Research, VA Ann Arbor Healthcare System, Ann Arbor, MI, USA.
J Gen Intern Med. 2017 Apr;32(Suppl 1):40-47. doi: 10.1007/s11606-017-3987-0.
Small Changes (SC) is a weight management approach that demonstrated superior 12-month outcomes compared to the existing MOVE! Weight Management Program at two Veterans Affairs (VA) sites. However, approaches are needed to help graduates of treatment continue to lose or maintain their weight over the longer term.
The purpose of the present study was to examine the effectiveness of a second year of low-intensity SC support compared to support offered by the usual care MOVE! programs.
Following participation in the year-long Aspiring to Lifelong Health in VA (ASPIRE-VA) randomized controlled trial, participants were invited to extend their participation in their assigned program for another year. Three programs were extended to include six SC sessions delivered via telephone (ASPIRE-Phone) or an in-person group (ASPIRE-Group), or 12 sessions offered by the MOVE! programs.
Three hundred thirty-two overweight/obese veterans who consented to extend their participation in the ASPIRE-VA trial by an additional year.
Twenty-four-month weight change (kg).
Twenty-four months after baseline, participants in all three groups had modest weight loss (-1.40 kg [-2.61 to -0.18] in the ASPIRE-Group, -2.13 kg [-3.43 to -0.83] in ASPIRE-Phone, and -1.78 kg [-3.07 to -0.49] in MOVE!), with no significant differences among the three groups. Exploratory post hoc analyses revealed that participants diagnosed with diabetes initially benefited from the ASPIRE-Group program (-2.6 kg [-4.37 to 0.83]), but experienced significant weight regain during the second year (+2.8 kg [0.92-4.69]) compared to those without diabetes.
Participants in all three programs lost weight and maintained a statistically significant, though clinically modest, amount of weight loss over a 24-month period. Although participants in the ASPIRE-Group initially had greater weight loss, treatment was not sufficient to sustain weight loss through the second year, particularly in veterans with diabetes. Consistent, continuous-care treatment is needed to address obesity in the VA.
“小改变”(SC)是一种体重管理方法,在两个退伍军人事务部(VA)站点与现有的“行动!”体重管理计划相比,显示出更优的12个月成效。然而,需要采取方法来帮助治疗毕业生在更长时间内持续减重或维持体重。
本研究的目的是检验与常规护理“行动!”计划提供的支持相比,第二年低强度SC支持的有效性。
在参与为期一年的退伍军人事务部终身健康追求(ASPIRE-VA)随机对照试验后,邀请参与者将其在分配计划中的参与再延长一年。三个计划进行了扩展,包括通过电话提供六次SC课程(ASPIRE-电话组)或面对面小组课程(ASPIRE-小组组),或由“行动!”计划提供12次课程。
332名超重/肥胖退伍军人,他们同意将参与ASPIRE-VA试验的时间再延长一年。
24个月体重变化(千克)。
基线后24个月,所有三组参与者均有适度体重减轻(ASPIRE-小组组为-1.40千克[-2.61至-0.18],ASPIRE-电话组为-2.13千克[-3.43至-0.83],“行动!”组为-1.78千克[-3.07至-0.49]),三组之间无显著差异。探索性事后分析显示,最初被诊断患有糖尿病的参与者从ASPIRE-小组组计划中受益(-2.6千克[-4.37至0.83]),但与未患糖尿病的参与者相比,在第二年体重显著反弹(+2.8千克[0.92 - 4.69])。
所有三个计划的参与者均减重,并在24个月期间维持了具有统计学意义但临床上适度的体重减轻量。尽管ASPIRE-小组组的参与者最初减重更多,但治疗不足以维持第二年的体重减轻,特别是在患有糖尿病的退伍军人中。退伍军人事务部需要持续、连贯的护理治疗来解决肥胖问题。