Eisenberg Nancy
Department of Psychology, Arizona State University, Tempe, AZ, USA.
J Child Psychol Psychiatry. 2017 Apr;58(4):384-386. doi: 10.1111/jcpp.12707.
In Nigg's excellent article, he deals with a variety of complex conceptual issues related to the constructs of self-regulation and executive functioning (EF). Overall, I agree that the terminology proposed by Nigg should be adopted; moreover, the conceptual distinctions he provides should help the field to move forward with regard to the understanding of varied constructs related to self-regulation. In the spirit of further clarification, I questioned Nigg's suggestions that (a) working memory should be considered as part of the construct of top-down regulation and (b) planning is a higher level component of EF but not part of effortful control. In addition, I discussed my perspective on the role of automaticity in defining top-down versus bottom-up self-regulatory processes and the role of flexibility in top-down self-regulatory processes and their relation to personality resiliency.
在尼格的精彩文章中,他探讨了与自我调节和执行功能(EF)结构相关的各种复杂概念问题。总体而言,我同意应采用尼格提出的术语;此外,他所提供的概念区分应有助于该领域在理解与自我调节相关的各种结构方面取得进展。本着进一步澄清的精神,我对尼格的以下建议提出质疑:(a)工作记忆应被视为自上而下调节结构的一部分;(b)计划是执行功能的一个更高层次的组成部分,但不是努力控制的一部分。此外,我还讨论了我对自动化在定义自上而下与自下而上自我调节过程中的作用、灵活性在自上而下自我调节过程中的作用及其与人格弹性的关系的看法。