McDougle Samuel D, Bond Krista M, Taylor Jordan A
Department of Psychology, Princeton University, Princeton, New Jersey; and
Princeton Neuroscience Institute, Princeton University, Princeton, New Jersey.
J Neurophysiol. 2017 Jul 1;118(1):383-393. doi: 10.1152/jn.00974.2016. Epub 2017 Apr 12.
Generalization is a fundamental aspect of behavior, allowing for the transfer of knowledge from one context to another. The details of this transfer are thought to reveal how the brain represents what it learns. Generalization has been a central focus in studies of sensorimotor adaptation, and its pattern has been well characterized: Learning of new dynamic and kinematic transformations in one region of space tapers off in a Gaussian-like fashion to neighboring untrained regions, echoing tuned population codes in the brain. In contrast to common allusions to generalization in cognitive science, generalization in visually guided reaching is usually framed as a passive consequence of neural tuning functions rather than a cognitive feature of learning. While previous research has presumed that maximum generalization occurs at the instructed task goal or the actual movement direction, recent work suggests that maximum generalization may occur at the location of an explicitly accessible movement plan. Here we provide further support for plan-based generalization, formalize this theory in an updated model of adaptation, and test several unexpected implications of the model. First, we employ a generalization paradigm to parameterize the generalization function and ascertain its maximum point. We then apply the derived generalization function to our model and successfully simulate and fit the time course of implicit adaptation across three behavioral experiments. We find that dynamics predicted by plan-based generalization are borne out in the data, are contrary to what traditional models predict, and lead to surprising implications for the behavioral, computational, and neural characteristics of sensorimotor adaptation. The pattern of generalization is thought to reveal how the motor system represents learned actions. Recent work has made the intriguing suggestion that maximum generalization in sensorimotor adaptation tasks occurs at the location of the learned movement plan. Here we support this interpretation, develop a novel model of motor adaptation that incorporates plan-based generalization, and use the model to successfully predict surprising dynamics in the time course of adaptation across several conditions.
泛化是行为的一个基本方面,它允许知识从一种情境转移到另一种情境。这种转移的细节被认为可以揭示大脑如何表征其所学到的东西。泛化一直是感觉运动适应研究的核心焦点,其模式已得到很好的刻画:在空间的一个区域学习新的动态和运动学变换会以类似高斯的方式逐渐减弱到相邻的未训练区域,这与大脑中调谐的群体编码相呼应。与认知科学中对泛化的常见暗示不同,视觉引导伸手动作中的泛化通常被视为神经调谐功能的被动结果,而不是学习的认知特征。虽然先前的研究假定最大泛化发生在指示的任务目标或实际运动方向上,但最近的研究表明,最大泛化可能发生在明确可及的运动计划的位置。在这里,我们为基于计划的泛化提供了进一步的支持,在一个更新的适应模型中对这一理论进行了形式化,并测试了该模型的几个意想不到的含义。首先,我们采用一种泛化范式来参数化泛化函数并确定其最大值点。然后,我们将导出的泛化函数应用于我们的模型,并成功地模拟和拟合了三个行为实验中隐式适应的时间进程。我们发现,基于计划的泛化所预测的动态在数据中得到了证实,与传统模型的预测相反,并对感觉运动适应的行为、计算和神经特征产生了令人惊讶的影响。泛化模式被认为可以揭示运动系统如何表征所学的动作。最近的研究提出了一个有趣的观点,即在感觉运动适应任务中,最大泛化发生在所学运动计划的位置。在这里,我们支持这一解释,开发了一种包含基于计划的泛化的新型运动适应模型,并使用该模型成功地预测了几种条件下适应过程中令人惊讶的动态。