Kalfaoğlu Çığır, Stafford Tom, Milne Elizabeth
Department of Psychology, University of Sheffield.
J Exp Psychol Hum Percept Perform. 2018 Jan;44(1):69-88. doi: 10.1037/xhp0000417. Epub 2017 Apr 27.
Performance errors are associated with robust behavioral and electroencephalography (EEG) effects. However, there is a debate about the nature of the relationship between these effects and implicit versus explicit error awareness. Our aim was to study the relationship between error related electrophysiological effects, such as spectral perturbations in fronto-medial theta band oscillations (FMT), and error awareness in typing. Typing has an advantage as an experimental paradigm in that detected errors are quickly and habitually signaled by the participant using backspace, allowing separation of detected from undetected errors without interruption in behavior. Typing is thought to be controlled hierarchically via inner and outer loops, which rely on different sources for error detection. Touch-typist participants were asked to copy-type 100 sentences as EEG was recorded in the absence of visual feedback. Continuous EEG data were analyzed using independent component analysis (ICA). Time-frequency and ERP analyses were applied to emergent independent components. The results show that single-trial FMT parameters and error related negativity (ERN) amplitude predict overt, adaptive posterror actions such as error correction via backspace; and, posterror slowing, reflecting implicit error awareness. In addition, we found that those uncorrected errors which were slowed down the most were also the ones associated with a high level of FMT activity. Our results as a whole show that FMT are related to neural mechanisms involved in explicit awareness of errors, and input from inner loop is sufficient for error correction in typing. (PsycINFO Database Record
执行错误与强大的行为和脑电图(EEG)效应相关。然而,关于这些效应与内隐和外显错误意识之间关系的本质存在争议。我们的目的是研究与错误相关的电生理效应,如额内侧θ频段振荡(FMT)中的频谱扰动,与打字过程中的错误意识之间的关系。打字作为一种实验范式具有优势,因为参与者使用退格键能快速且习惯性地标记出检测到的错误,从而能够在行为不中断的情况下将检测到的错误与未检测到的错误区分开来。打字被认为是通过内循环和外循环进行分层控制的,这两种循环依赖于不同的错误检测源。在没有视觉反馈的情况下记录脑电图时,要求触摸打字员参与者复制输入100个句子。使用独立成分分析(ICA)对连续的脑电图数据进行分析。将时频分析和事件相关电位(ERP)分析应用于出现的独立成分。结果表明,单次试验的FMT参数和错误相关负波(ERN)幅度可预测明显的、适应性的错误后动作,如通过退格键进行错误纠正;以及错误后反应减慢,这反映了内隐错误意识。此外,我们发现那些减慢程度最大的未纠正错误也是与高水平FMT活动相关的错误。我们的整体结果表明,FMT与涉及错误外显意识的神经机制有关,并且内循环的输入足以在打字过程中进行错误纠正。(PsycINFO数据库记录)