Midford Richard, Kirsner Kim
a National Drug Research Institute Curtin University of Technology.
b Psychology Department , University of Western Australia.
Neuropsychol Dev Cogn B Aging Neuropsychol Cogn. 2005 Dec;12(4):359-387. doi: 10.1080/13825580500246894.
There is a wealth of evidence that learning ability declines with age. In almost all of the studies however, the performance measures employed are explicit, even though research has consistently indicated that aged adults have well preserved implicit learning ability. This suggests that under certain circumstances aged adults should be at no great learning disadvantage in comparison to young adults. This experiment used the artificial grammar-learning paradigm, developed by Reber, in a 2 X 2 factorial design that involved systematic manipulation of grammatical complexity and rule provision. The study explored how each combination of conditions influenced explicit or implicit learning and the relationship between learning style and performance by aged and young adults. Learning was assessed primarily by recognition accuracy, involving correct and incorrect grammar exemplars. However, reaction time, error pattern, reliability, and verbal report data was also collected as a way of confirming and providing added detail on learning performance patterns. Aged adults, irrespective of experimental learning conditions, evidenced a remarkably consistent reaction time deficit. In contrast, the accuracy differential between age groups varied markedly across the four treatments. The most salient contrast occurred between complex grammar, without rules, where there was no difference in accuracy between the two age groups and simple grammar, with rules, where the difference was greatest. This change in learning performance between these two conditions indicates that aged adults will learn as well as young adults in situations where the knowledge domain is conducive to implicit learning.
有大量证据表明学习能力会随着年龄的增长而下降。然而,在几乎所有的研究中,所采用的表现测量都是显性的,尽管研究一直表明老年人的隐性学习能力保存完好。这表明在某些情况下,与年轻人相比,老年人在学习方面不应处于极大的劣势。本实验采用了由雷伯开发的人工语法学习范式,采用2×2析因设计,系统地操纵语法复杂性和规则提供情况。该研究探讨了每种条件组合如何影响显性或隐性学习,以及老年人和年轻人的学习风格与表现之间的关系。学习主要通过识别准确性来评估,包括正确和错误的语法范例。然而,反应时间、错误模式、可靠性和口头报告数据也被收集起来,作为确认和提供学习表现模式更多细节的一种方式。无论实验学习条件如何,老年人都表现出明显一致的反应时间缺陷。相比之下,年龄组之间的准确性差异在四种处理中差异显著。最显著的对比出现在无规则的复杂语法和有规则的简单语法之间,在无规则的复杂语法中,两个年龄组的准确性没有差异,而在有规则的简单语法中,差异最大。这两种条件下学习表现的变化表明,在知识领域有利于隐性学习的情况下,老年人的学习效果与年轻人一样好。