Tummala Subhash, Singhal Tarun, Oommen Vinit V, Kim Gloria, Khalid Fariha, Healy Brian C, Bakshi Rohit
Int J MS Care. 2017 May-Jun;19(3):158-164. doi: 10.7224/1537-2073.2016-068.
Monitoring patients with multiple sclerosis (MS) for “no evidence of disease activity” (NEDA) may help guide disease-modifying therapy (DMT) management decisions. Whereas surveillance brain magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is common, the role of spinal cord monitoring for NEDA is unknown.
To evaluate the role of brain and spinal cord 3T MRI in the 1-year evaluation of NEDA.
Of 61 study patients (3 clinically isolated syndrome, 56 relapsing-remitting, 2 secondary progressive), 56 (91.8%) were receiving DMT. The MRI included brain fluid-attenuated inversion recovery and cervical/thoracic T2-weighted fast spin echo images. On MRI, NEDA was defined as the absence of new or enlarging T2 lesions at 1 year.
Thirty-nine patients (63.9%) achieved NEDA by brain MRI, only one of whom had spinal cord activity. This translates to a false-positive rate for NEDA based on the brain of 2.6% (95% CI, 0.1%–13.5%). Thirty-eight patients (62.3%) had NEDA by brain and spinal cord MRI. Fifty-five patients (90.2%) had NEDA by spinal cord MRI, 17 of whom had brain activity. Of the 22 patients (36.1%) with brain changes, 5 had spinal cord changes. No evidence of disease activity was sustained in 48.3% of patients at 1 year and was the same with the addition of spinal cord MRI. Patients with MRI activity in either the brain or the spinal cord only were more likely to have activity in the brain (P = .0001).
Spinal cord MRI had a low diagnostic yield as an adjunct to brain MRI at 3T in monitoring patients with MS for NEDA over 1 year. Studies with larger data sets are needed to confirm these findings.
对多发性硬化症(MS)患者进行“无疾病活动证据”(NEDA)监测可能有助于指导疾病修饰治疗(DMT)管理决策。虽然监测脑部磁共振成像(MRI)很常见,但脊髓监测对NEDA的作用尚不清楚。
评估脑部和脊髓3T MRI在NEDA 1年评估中的作用。
61例研究患者中(3例临床孤立综合征,56例复发缓解型,2例继发进展型),56例(91.8%)正在接受DMT治疗。MRI包括脑部液体衰减反转恢复序列和颈椎/胸椎T2加权快速自旋回波图像。在MRI上,NEDA被定义为1年内无新的或扩大的T2病变。
39例患者(63.9%)通过脑部MRI达到NEDA,其中只有1例有脊髓活动。这意味着基于脑部的NEDA假阳性率为2.6%(95%CI,0.1%–13.5%)。38例患者(62.3%)通过脑部和脊髓MRI达到NEDA。55例患者(90.2%)通过脊髓MRI达到NEDA,其中17例有脑部活动。在22例(36.1%)有脑部改变的患者中,5例有脊髓改变。48.3%的患者在1年时无疾病活动证据,加上脊髓MRI后情况相同。仅脑部或脊髓有MRI活动的患者更有可能脑部有活动(P = .0001)。
在3T时,脊髓MRI作为脑部MRI的辅助手段,在监测MS患者1年以上的NEDA方面诊断率较低。需要更大数据集的研究来证实这些发现。