GRASP-Research Group, Department of Neuroscience, KU Leuven, Leuven, Belgium.
University Psychiatric Center, KU Leuven, Leuven, Belgium.
J Child Psychol Psychiatry. 2017 Dec;58(12):1301-1309. doi: 10.1111/jcpp.12766. Epub 2017 Jun 28.
Most gene-environment interaction studies (G × E) have focused on single candidate genes. This approach is criticized for its expectations of large effect sizes and occurrence of spurious results. We describe an approach that accounts for the polygenic nature of most psychiatric phenotypes and reduces the risk of false-positive findings. We apply this method focusing on the role of perceived parental support, psychological control, and harsh punishment in depressive symptoms in adolescence.
Analyses were conducted on 982 adolescents of Caucasian origin (M (SD) = 13.78 (.94) years) genotyped for 4,947 SNPs in 263 genes, selected based on a literature survey. The Leuven Adolescent Perceived Parenting Scale (LAPPS) and the Parental Behavior Scale (PBS) were used to assess perceived parental psychological control, harsh punishment, and support. The Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale (CES-D) was the outcome. We used gene-based testing taking into account linkage disequilibrium to identify genes containing SNPs exhibiting an interaction with environmental factors yielding a p-value per single gene. Significant results at the corrected p-value of p < 1.90 × 10 were examined in an independent replication sample of Dutch adolescents (N = 1354).
Two genes showed evidence for interaction with perceived support: GABRR1 (p = 4.62 × 10 ) and GABRR2 (p = 9.05 × 10 ). No genes interacted significantly with psychological control or harsh punishment. Gene-based analysis was unable to confirm the interaction of GABRR1 or GABRR2 with support in the replication sample. However, for GABRR2, but not GABRR1, the correlation of the estimates between the two datasets was significant (r (46) = .32; p = .027) and a gene-based analysis of the combined datasets supported GABRR2 × support interaction (p = 1.63 × 10 ).
We present a gene-based method for gene-environment interactions in a polygenic context and show that genes interact differently with particular aspects of parenting. This accentuates the importance of polygenic approaches and the need to accurately assess environmental exposure in G × E.
大多数基因-环境交互作用研究(G×E)都集中在单一候选基因上。这种方法因其预期的大效应量和虚假结果的出现而受到批评。我们描述了一种方法,该方法考虑到大多数精神疾病表型的多基因性质,并降低了假阳性发现的风险。我们应用这种方法,重点关注感知到的父母支持、心理控制和严厉惩罚在青少年抑郁症状中的作用。
对 982 名白种人青少年进行了分析(M(SD)=13.78(.94)岁),这些青少年根据文献调查,对 263 个基因中的 4947 个 SNP 进行了基因分型。使用莱顿青少年感知父母教养量表(LAPPS)和父母行为量表(PBS)评估感知到的父母心理控制、严厉惩罚和支持。以流行病学研究中心抑郁量表(CES-D)为结局。我们使用考虑连锁不平衡的基于基因的测试来识别包含与环境因素相互作用的 SNP 的基因,从而为单个基因提供 p 值。在荷兰青少年的独立复制样本(N=1354)中,对校正后 p 值小于 1.90×10 的显著结果进行了检验。
有两个基因显示出与感知支持相互作用的证据:GABRR1(p=4.62×10)和 GABRR2(p=9.05×10)。没有基因与心理控制或严厉惩罚有显著相互作用。基于基因的分析无法在复制样本中确认 GABRR1 或 GABRR2 与支持的相互作用。然而,对于 GABRR2,但不是 GABRR1,两个数据集之间的估计相关性是显著的(r(46)=0.32;p=0.027),并且对合并数据集的基于基因的分析支持 GABRR2×支持相互作用(p=1.63×10)。
我们提出了一种在多基因背景下进行基因-环境相互作用的基于基因的方法,并表明基因与特定的育儿方面相互作用不同。这强调了多基因方法的重要性,以及在 G×E 中准确评估环境暴露的必要性。