Quality Department, Vestre Viken HF, Drammen, Buskerud, Norway.
Institute of Health and Society, Faculty of Medicine, University of Oslo, Oslo, Norway.
BMJ Qual Saf. 2017 Oct;26(10):806-816. doi: 10.1136/bmjqs-2017-006517. Epub 2017 Jul 4.
On 22 July 2011, Norway suffered a devastating terrorist attack targeting a political youth camp on a remote island. Within a few hours, 35 injured terrorist victims were admitted to the local Ringerike community hospital. All victims survived. The local emergency medical service (EMS), despite limited resources, was evaluated by three external bodies as successful in handling this crisis. This study investigates the determinants for the success of that EMS as a model for quality improvement in healthcare.
We performed focus group interviews using the critical incident technique with 30 healthcare professionals involved in the care of the attack victims to establish determinants of the EMS' success. Two independent teams of professional experts classified and validated the identified determinants.
Our findings suggest a combination of four elements essential for the success of the EMS: (1) major emergency preparedness and competence based on continuous planning, training and learning; (2) crisis management based on knowledge, trust and data collection; (3) empowerment through multiprofessional networks; and (4) the ability to improvise based on acquired structure and competence. The informants reported the successful response was specifically based on multiprofessional trauma education, team training, and prehospital and in-hospital networking including mental healthcare. The powerful combination of preparedness, competence and crisis management built on empowerment enabled the healthcare workers to trust themselves and each other to make professional decisions and creative improvisations in an unpredictable situation.
The determinants for success derived from this qualitative study (preparedness, management, networking, ability to improvise) may be universally applicable to understanding the conditions for resilient and safe healthcare services, and of general interest for quality improvement in healthcare.
2011 年 7 月 22 日,挪威遭受了一场毁灭性的恐怖袭击,目标是一个偏远岛屿上的政治青年营地。在几个小时内,35 名受伤的恐怖袭击受害者被送往当地的林格克社区医院。所有受害者都幸存了下来。尽管当地的紧急医疗服务(EMS)资源有限,但三个外部机构评估认为,该机构在处理这场危机方面取得了成功。本研究旨在调查 EMS 成功的决定因素,将其作为医疗保健质量改进的模型。
我们使用关键事件技术进行了焦点小组访谈,共有 30 名参与治疗袭击受害者的医疗保健专业人员参与,以确定 EMS 成功的决定因素。两个独立的专业专家团队对确定的决定因素进行了分类和验证。
我们的研究结果表明,EMS 成功的关键要素有四个:(1)基于持续规划、培训和学习的重大应急准备和能力;(2)基于知识、信任和数据收集的危机管理;(3)通过多专业网络授权;(4)基于已获得的结构和能力进行即兴创作的能力。受访者报告称,成功的应对措施特别基于多专业创伤教育、团队培训以及包括心理健康护理在内的院前和院内网络。准备、能力和危机管理的强大结合建立在授权的基础上,使医疗保健工作者能够在不可预测的情况下信任自己和彼此,做出专业决策和创造性的即兴创作。
从这项定性研究中得出的成功决定因素(准备、管理、网络、即兴创作能力)可能普遍适用于理解弹性和安全医疗保健服务的条件,并且对医疗保健质量改进具有普遍意义。