Wang Yuanyuan, Liu Weiwei, Shi Huifeng, Liu Chaojie, Wang Yan
Department of Maternal and Child Health, School of Public Health, Peking University, Beijing, China.
Second Outpatient Department, Peking University Third Hospital, Beijing, China.
BMJ Open. 2017 Jul 12;7(7):e015458. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2016-015458.
Patient safety culture (PSC) plays a critical role in ensuring safe and quality care. Extensive PSC studies have been undertaken in hospitals. However, little is known about PSC in maternal and child health (MCH) institutions in China, which provide both population-based preventive services as well as individual care for patients.
This study aimed to develop a theoretical framework for conceptualising PSC in MCH institutions in China.
The study was undertaken in six MCH institutions (three in Hebei and three in Beijing). Participants (n=118) were recruited through stratified purposive sampling: 20 managers/administrators, 59 care providers and 39 patients. In-depth interviews were conducted with the participants. The interview data were coded using both inductive (based on the existing PSC theory developed by the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality) and deductive (open coding arising from data) approaches. A PSC framework was formulated through axial coding that connected initial codes and selective coding that extracted a small number of themes.
The interviewees considered patient safety in relation to six aspects: safety and security in public spaces, safety of medical services, privacy and information security, financial security, psychological safety and gap in services. A 12-dimensional PSC framework was developed, containing 69 items. While the existing PSC theory was confirmed by this study, some new themes emerged from the data. Patients expressed particular concerns about psychological safety and financial security. Defensive medical practices emerged as a PSC dimension that is associated with not only medical safety but also financial security and psychological safety. Patient engagement was also valued by the interviewees, especially the patients, as part of PSC.
Although there are some common features in PSC across different healthcare delivery systems, PSC can also be context specific. In MCH settings in China, the meaning of 'patient safety' goes beyond the traditional definition of patients. General well-being, health and disease prevention are important anchor points for defining PSC in such settings.
患者安全文化(PSC)在确保安全和高质量医疗服务方面发挥着关键作用。医院中已经开展了广泛的患者安全文化研究。然而,在中国提供基于人群的预防服务以及针对患者的个性化护理的妇幼保健(MCH)机构中,对于患者安全文化的了解却很少。
本研究旨在构建一个理论框架,用于对中国妇幼保健机构中的患者安全文化进行概念化。
该研究在六家妇幼保健机构(河北三家,北京三家)进行。通过分层目的抽样招募了参与者(n = 118):20名管理人员/行政人员、59名医护人员和39名患者。对参与者进行了深入访谈。访谈数据使用归纳法(基于医疗保健研究与质量局开发的现有患者安全文化理论)和演绎法(由数据产生的开放编码)进行编码。通过将初始代码连接起来的轴心编码和提取少量主题的选择编码,制定了一个患者安全文化框架。
受访者从六个方面考虑患者安全:公共场所的安全保障、医疗服务安全、隐私和信息安全、财务安全、心理安全以及服务差距。开发了一个包含69项内容的12维度患者安全文化框架。虽然本研究证实了现有的患者安全文化理论,但数据中也出现了一些新主题。患者对心理安全和财务安全表达了特别关注。防御性医疗行为作为患者安全文化的一个维度出现,它不仅与医疗安全相关联,还与财务安全和心理安全相关联。受访者,尤其是患者,也重视患者参与作为患者安全文化的一部分。
尽管不同医疗服务系统中的患者安全文化存在一些共同特征,但患者安全文化也可能因具体情况而异。在中国的妇幼保健环境中,“患者安全”的含义超出了对患者的传统定义。总体福祉、健康和疾病预防是在此类环境中定义患者安全文化的重要切入点。