Charupanit K, Lopour B A
Department of Biomedical Engineering, Henry Samueli School of Engineering, 3120 Natural Sciences II, University of California, Irvine, CA, 92697-2715, USA.
Brain Topogr. 2017 Nov;30(6):724-738. doi: 10.1007/s10548-017-0579-6. Epub 2017 Jul 26.
High frequency oscillations (HFOs) are a promising biomarker of epileptic tissue, but detection of these electrographic events remains a challenge. Automatic detectors show encouraging results, but they typically require optimization of multiple parameters, which is a barrier to good performance and broad applicability. We therefore propose a new automatic HFO detection algorithm, focusing on simplicity and ease of implementation. It requires tuning of only an amplitude threshold, which can be determined by an iterative process or directly calculated from statistics of the rectified filtered data (i.e. mean plus standard deviation). The iterative approach uses an estimate of the amplitude probability distribution of the background activity to calculate the optimum threshold for identification of transient high amplitude events. We tested both the iterative and non-iterative approaches using a dataset of visually marked HFOs, and we compared the performance to a commonly used detector based on the root-mean-square. When the threshold was optimized for individual channels via ROC curve, all three methods were comparable. The iterative detector achieved a sensitivity of 99.6%, false positive rate (FPR) of 1.1%, and false detection rate (FDR) of 37.3%. However, in an eight-fold cross-validation test, the iterative method had better sensitivity than the other two methods (80.0% compared to 64.4 and 65.8%), with FPR and FDR of 1.3, and 49.4%, respectively. The simplicity of this algorithm, with only a single parameter, will enable consistent application of automatic detection across research centers and recording modalities, and it may therefore be a powerful tool for the assessment and localization of epileptic activity.
高频振荡(HFOs)是一种很有前景的癫痫组织生物标志物,但检测这些电描记事件仍然是一项挑战。自动检测方法显示出令人鼓舞的结果,但通常需要对多个参数进行优化,这对良好性能和广泛适用性构成了障碍。因此,我们提出了一种新的自动HFO检测算法,重点在于简单性和易于实现。它只需要调整一个幅度阈值,该阈值可以通过迭代过程确定,也可以直接从整流滤波后的数据统计量(即均值加标准差)计算得出。迭代方法使用背景活动幅度概率分布的估计值来计算识别瞬态高幅度事件的最佳阈值。我们使用视觉标记的HFO数据集测试了迭代和非迭代方法,并将性能与基于均方根的常用检测器进行了比较。当通过ROC曲线针对各个通道优化阈值时,所有三种方法相当。迭代检测器的灵敏度达到99.6%,假阳性率(FPR)为1.1%,误检率(FDR)为37.3%。然而,在八折交叉验证测试中,迭代方法的灵敏度优于其他两种方法(分别为80.0%,而其他两种方法为64.4%和65.8%),FPR和FDR分别为1.3%和49.4%。该算法的简单性,仅一个参数,将使自动检测能够在各研究中心和记录方式中得到一致应用,因此它可能是评估和定位癫痫活动的有力工具。