Kovacs Gregory T A, Shadden Mark
Department of Electrical Engineering, Stanford University, Stanford, California, United States of America.
Elite Research, LLC, Irving, Texas, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2017 Jul 27;12(7):e0181381. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0181381. eCollection 2017.
NASA's periodic selection of astronauts is a highly selective process accepting applications from the general population, wherein the mechanics of selection are not made public. This research was an effort to determine if biases (specifically age) exist in the process and, if so, at which points they might manifest. Two sets of analyses were conducted. The first utilized data requested via the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) on NASA astronaut applicants for the 2009 and 2013 selection years. Using a series of multinomial and logistic regressions, the data were analyzed to uncover whether age of the applicants linearly or nonlinearly affected their likelihood of receiving an invitation, as well as their likelihood of being selected into the astronaut program. The second used public data on age at selection and age at other career milestones for every astronaut selected from 1959 to 2013 to analyze trends in age over time using ordinary least-squares (OLS) regression and Pearson's correlation. The results for the FOIA data revealed a nonlinear relationship between age and receiving an interview, as well as age and selection into the astronaut program, but the most striking observation was the loss of age diversity at each stage of selection. Applicants younger or older than approximately 40 years were significantly less likely to receive invitations for interviews and were significantly less likely to be selected as an astronaut. Analysis of the public-source data for all selections since the beginning of the astronaut program revealed significant age trends over time including a gradual increase in selectee age and decreased tenure at NASA after last flight, with average age at retirement steady over the entire history of the astronaut program at approximately 48 years.
美国国家航空航天局(NASA)定期选拔宇航员是一个高度严格的过程,接受来自普通大众的申请,但其选拔机制并不公开。这项研究旨在确定该过程中是否存在偏见(特别是年龄方面),如果存在,这些偏见可能在哪些环节显现。研究进行了两组分析。第一组分析利用了根据《信息自由法案》(FOIA)获取的2009年和2013年选拔年份的NASA宇航员申请者数据。通过一系列多项和逻辑回归分析这些数据,以揭示申请者的年龄是否以线性或非线性方式影响他们收到邀请的可能性,以及被选入宇航员计划的可能性。第二组分析使用了1959年至2013年期间选拔的每位宇航员在入选时的年龄以及其他职业里程碑时的年龄的公开数据,通过普通最小二乘法(OLS)回归和皮尔逊相关性分析年龄随时间的趋势。FOIA数据的结果显示,年龄与获得面试机会以及年龄与被选入宇航员计划之间存在非线性关系,但最引人注目的观察结果是在选拔的每个阶段年龄多样性的丧失。年龄小于或大于约40岁的申请者获得面试邀请的可能性显著降低,被选为宇航员的可能性也显著降低。对自宇航员计划开始以来所有选拔的公开来源数据的分析显示,随着时间的推移存在显著的年龄趋势,包括入选者年龄逐渐增加以及最后一次飞行后在NASA的任期缩短,在宇航员计划的整个历史中退休平均年龄稳定在约48岁。