Jackson Samuel J, Thomas Gareth J
National Centre for the Replacement, Refinement and Reduction of Animals in Research, Gibbs Building, 215 Euston Road, London NW1 2BE, UK
Cancer Sciences Unit, Faculty of Medicine, University of Southampton, Somers Building, MP 824 Tremona Road, Southampton SO16 6YD, UK.
Dis Model Mech. 2017 Aug 1;10(8):939-942. doi: 10.1242/dmm.031260.
Mouse models, including patient-derived xenograft mice, are widely used to address questions in cancer research. However, there are documented flaws in these models that can result in the misrepresentation of human tumour biology and limit the suitability of the model for translational research. A coordinated effort to promote the more widespread development and use of 'non-animal human tissue' models could provide a clinically relevant platform for many cancer studies, maximising the opportunities presented by human tissue resources such as biobanks. A number of key factors limit the wide adoption of non-animal human tissue models in cancer research, including deficiencies in the infrastructure and the technical tools required to collect, transport, store and maintain human tissue for lab use. Another obstacle is the long-standing cultural reliance on animal models, which can make researchers resistant to change, often because of concerns about historical data compatibility and losing ground in a competitive environment while new approaches are embedded in lab practice. There are a wide range of initiatives that aim to address these issues by facilitating data sharing and promoting collaborations between organisations and researchers who work with human tissue. The importance of coordinating biobanks and introducing quality standards is gaining momentum. There is an exciting opportunity to transform cancer drug discovery by optimising the use of human tissue and reducing the reliance on potentially less predictive animal models.
包括患者来源的异种移植小鼠在内的小鼠模型被广泛用于解决癌症研究中的问题。然而,这些模型存在一些已被记录的缺陷,可能导致对人类肿瘤生物学的错误表述,并限制该模型在转化研究中的适用性。共同努力促进“非动物人类组织”模型更广泛的开发和使用,可以为许多癌症研究提供一个与临床相关的平台,最大限度地利用生物样本库等人类组织资源带来的机会。一些关键因素限制了非动物人类组织模型在癌症研究中的广泛采用,包括基础设施以及收集、运输、储存和维护供实验室使用的人类组织所需的技术工具存在不足。另一个障碍是长期以来在文化上对动物模型的依赖,这可能使研究人员抵制变革,通常是因为担心历史数据的兼容性以及在新方法融入实验室实践时在竞争环境中落后。有各种各样的举措旨在通过促进数据共享以及推动使用人类组织的组织和研究人员之间的合作来解决这些问题。协调生物样本库并引入质量标准的重要性正在增强。通过优化人类组织的使用并减少对潜在预测性较低的动物模型的依赖,存在着变革癌症药物发现的令人兴奋的机会。