Feo Claudio F, Ginesu Giorgio C, Bellini Alessandro, Cherchi Giuseppe, Scanu Antonio M, Cossu Maria Laura, Fancellu Alessandro, Porcu Alberto
Unit of General Surgery 2, Department of Clinical and Experimental Medicine, University of Sassari, Viale San Pietro 43, 07100, Sassari, Italy.
Ann Med Surg (Lond). 2017 Jul 25;21:81-84. doi: 10.1016/j.amsu.2017.07.056. eCollection 2017 Sep.
Totally implantable venous access devices (TIVADs) represent a convenient way for the administration of medications or nutrients. Traditionally, chest ports have been positioned by surgeons in the operating room, however there has been a transition over the years to port insertion by interventional radiologists in the radiology suite. The optimal method for chest port placement is still under debate.
Data on all adult patients undergoing isolated chest port placement at our institution in a 12-year period were retrospectively reviewed. The aim of this cohort study was to compare cost and morbidity for chest port insertion in two different settings: outpatient clinic and operating room.
Between 2003 and 2015 a total of 527 chest ports were placed in adult patients. Of them, 262 procedures were performed in the operating room and 265 procedures were undertaken in the outpatient clinic. Patient characteristics were similar and there was no significant difference in early (<30 days, p = 0.54) and late complications (30-120 days, p = 0.53). The average charge for placement of a chest port was 1270 Euros in the operating room 620 Euros in the outpatient clinic.
Our results suggest that chest ports can be safely placed in most patients under local anesthesia in the office setting without fluoroscopy or ultrasound guidance. Future randomized controlled studies may evaluate if surgeons or interventional radiologists should routinely perform these procedures in a dedicated office setting and reserve more sophisticated facilities only for patients at high risk of technical failure.
完全植入式静脉通路装置(TIVADs)是一种方便的给药或营养输注方式。传统上,胸部端口由外科医生在手术室放置,然而多年来已逐渐过渡为由介入放射科医生在放射科进行端口植入。胸部端口放置的最佳方法仍存在争议。
回顾性分析了我院12年间所有接受单纯胸部端口植入的成年患者的数据。这项队列研究的目的是比较在两种不同环境下(门诊和手术室)进行胸部端口植入的成本和发病率。
2003年至2015年间,成年患者共植入527个胸部端口。其中,262例手术在手术室进行,265例手术在门诊进行。患者特征相似,早期(<30天,p = 0.54)和晚期并发症(30 - 120天,p = 0.53)无显著差异。手术室放置胸部端口的平均费用为1270欧元,门诊为620欧元。
我们的结果表明,在门诊局部麻醉下,大多数患者无需透视或超声引导即可安全地放置胸部端口。未来的随机对照研究可能会评估外科医生或介入放射科医生是否应在专门的门诊环境中常规进行这些操作,而仅为技术失败风险高的患者保留更先进的设施。